II
111th CONGRESS
1st Session
S. 1458
IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
July 16, 2009
Ms. Landrieu (for herself and Mr. Inhofe) introduced the following bill; which was read twice and referred to the Committee on Foreign Relations
A BILL
To encourage the development and implementation of a comprehensive, global strategy for the preservation and reunification of families and the provision of permanent parental care for orphans.
Short title
This Act may be cited as
the Families for Orphans Act of
2009
.
Findings and purposes
Findings
Congress makes the following findings:
A child who grows up in a permanent family in an atmosphere of happiness, love, and understanding has the best opportunity for the full and harmonious development of his or her potential.
The right of a child to grow up in a safe, loving, and permanent relationship with a responsible adult is a basic human right.
The safety and well-being of children should be the paramount concern of child welfare policies and programs.
As stated in the
United Nations Programme for the International Year of the Family (1994),
the family provides the natural framework for the emotional, financial,
and material support essential to the growth and development of its members,
particularly infants and children.
.
Cost benefit analysis data shows that effective, high quality interventions to improve parenting skills and reduce child maltreatment save between $2 and $8 for every dollar spent.
Despite the good efforts of countless governments and nongovernmental organizations, millions of children remain outside of the protection, permanency, safety, and love of a family. Without the care of a family, these children are forced to live on the streets, in child-headed households, or in institutions.
According to UNICEF, there are more than 132,000,000 orphans worldwide. Unless immediate action is taken, the number of orphans is expected to increase over time.
According to Dr. Dana Johnson at the University of Minnesota, lack of stimulation and consistent caregivers, suboptimal nutrition and physical and sexual abuse all conspire to delay and sometimes preclude normal development, speech acquisition, and attainment of necessary social skills. Children lose 1 month of linear growth for every 3 months in an orphanage.
Research indicates that infants who do not receive touching, holding, and stimulation fail to thrive and may suffer life-affecting physical and emotional stressors, if not death.
Although governments throughout the world are seeking models for preventing institutionalization and finding permanent families for orphaned children, many lack the resources or infrastructure to adequately address this need.
As a result of its efforts to protect its children from abuse and neglect, the United States has amassed a vast body of research, policy, and the professional capacity to promote safety, permanency, and well-being for children and youth so they can become healthy and successful adults.
Despite the fact that the United States invests $300,000,000,000 annually in international aid programs that are improving the health, safety, and well-being of children throughout the world, it is unclear how much of this funding is used to support the preservation and reunification of families or the provision of permanent parental care.
Greater coordination is needed between Federal bureaus and agencies with an interest in orphan care policy. Such efforts would be greatly assisted by the development of a comprehensive global strategy for providing permanent parental care for orphans.
Despite the United States’ interest in developing a comprehensive global strategy for providing permanent parental care for orphans, the United States lacks a clear, dedicated, diplomatic authority to represent these interests.
Purposes
The purposes of this Act are to—
provide the infrastructure and resources necessary for the United States to develop and implement a comprehensive, global strategy for the preservation and reunification of families and the provision of permanent parental care for orphans;
streamline and coordinate United States policies and programs related to the preservation and reunification of families and the provision of permanent parental care for orphans;
encourage and assist foreign governments in the development and implementation of effective child welfare policies, systems, and programs that preserve and reunify families and provide permanent parental care for orphans;
ensure that all aid efforts receiving funding from the United States recognize and support the need for the preservation and reunification of families and the provision of permanent parental care for orphans; and
build global awareness of the need for the preservation and reunification of families and the provision of permanent parental care for orphans.
Definitions
In this Act:
Adoption support services
The term adoption support services means services and activities designed to encourage adoption that is determined to be in the best interests of children, including—
pre- and post-adoption services; and
activities designed to expedite the adoption process and support adoptive families.
Deinstitutionalization
The term deinstitutionalization means the process of safely moving youth from institutions to—
permanent parental care; or
temporary alternatives designed to lead to permanent parental care.
Family at risk of dissolution
The term family at risk of dissolution means a family under circumstances which—
compromise the health, safety, and well-being of minor, dependent children to an extent that the parental caregivers may be compelled to voluntarily or involuntarily forfeit care, parental rights, or custody of such children; or
are likely to cause the parents to abandon or relinquish rights to minor, dependent children.
Family preservation
The term family preservation means services for children and families designed to promote the safety and well-being of children and families and to help families (at risk or in crisis, including community-based family support, social, therapeutic, and financial programs and services designed to—
enable families to provide safe, permanent, and nurturing care to their children; and
strengthen and support families who are at risk of dissolution, separation, or domestic violence.
Institution
The term institution means—
an orphanage;
a children’s home;
a boarding school for orphans;
a shelter;
a residential facility;
a hospital;
a dormitory;
long-term foster care; and
any other setting in which permanent parental care is not being provided to the child.
Institutionalized child
The term institutionalized child means a child who—
is younger than 21 years of age; and
lives in an institution.
Legal guardianship
The term legal guardianship means a legally recognized relationship between a child and a caretaker, which is intended to be permanent and is evidenced by the transfer to the caretaker of parental rights with respect to the child, including the rights of protection, education, custody, and decisionmaking.
Legal kinship
The term legal kinship means a legally recognized relationship between a child and a relative, which is intended to be permanent and is evidenced by the transfer to a relative of parental rights with respect to the child, including the rights of protection, education, custody, and decisionmaking.
Orphan
The term orphan means any child—
who lacks permanent parental care because of the death, the disappearance of, or the legal, permanent relinquishment of such child by both parents;
who is living in the care and custody of an institution;
whose biological parents’ rights have been legally terminated; or
whose country of origin has determined that the child lacks permanent parental care.
Permanent parental care
The term permanent parental care—
means a legally recognized relationship between an adult and a child who is younger than 21 years of age, which is life-long and provides a caring, safe, stable physical environment;
includes—
domestic and international adoption;
legal guardianship; and
legal kinship; and
does not include temporary or long-term foster care, institutionalization, or mentoring.
Reunification
The term reunification means time-limited services and activities provided to an orphan in order to facilitate the safe and timely reunification of the child and parent.
Office for Orphan Policy Diplomacy and Development
Establishment
There
is established within the Department of State the Office for Orphan Policy
Diplomacy and Development (referred to in this section as the
Office
), which shall promote and support—
the preservation and reunification of families; and
the provision of permanent parental care for orphans.
Coordinator
Appointment
The
Office shall be headed by the Coordinator for Orphan Policy Diplomacy and
Development (referred to in this section as the Coordinator
),
who shall be appointed by the President.
Qualifications
To the extent possible, the Coordinator shall be an individual with background and experience in the development of permanency related policies and systems.
Duties
The Coordinator shall—
oversee and coordinate—
all programs and duties authorized in this Act; and
all other activities that the United States Government conducts in furtherance of the purposes of this Act; and
carry out the functions described in subsection (c).
Authority
The Coordinator shall report directly to the Secretary of State.
Functions
Advisory
Unless otherwise specified in law, the Coordinator shall serve as the primary advisor to the Secretary of State and the President in all matters related to—
global family preservation and reunification; and
the provision of permanent parental care for orphans.
Diplomatic representation
In general
Subject to the direction of the President and the Secretary of State, the Coordinator shall represent the United States in matters and cases relevant to family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care in—
contacts with foreign governments, nongovernmental organizations, intergovernmental agencies, and specialized agencies of the United Nations and other international organizations of which the United States is a member;
multilateral conferences and meetings relevant to family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care for orphaned children; and
fulfillment of the diplomatic responsibilities designated to the central authority under title I of the Intercountry Adoption Act of 2000 (42 U.S.C. 14911 et seq.).
Waiver
The Secretary of State may waive the requirements under subparagraph (A) if—
representation by the Coordinator would interfere with the Secretary’s constitutional duty to represent the United States; or
representation by another high level official would be more appropriate or beneficial.
Policy development
In general
The Coordinator shall—
advise and support the Secretary of State in the development of a comprehensive, global strategy to promote the preservation and reunification of families and the provision of permanent parental care for orphans; and
advise and support foreign governments with the development of sound policy regarding—
the preservation and reunification of families; and
the provision of permanent parental care for orphans.
Best practices
In developing policies under this Act, the Coordinator shall identify and engage the best practices in family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care derived from a wide variety of domestic and global policy and practice leaders.
Cultural sensitivity
In developing policies under this Act, the Coordinator shall take into account cultural norms for each country to the extent consistent with the overall purposes of this Act.
Principle of subsidiarity
In developing policies and programs under this Act, the Coordinator shall—
attempt to reunify children with their families before pursuing adoption, legal kinship, legal guardianship, or domestic adoption; and
ensure that reasonable efforts are made to provide permanent parental care domestically before internationally.
Technical assistance
The Coordinator shall provide technical assistance to foreign countries to help build their capacities to strengthen family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care policies, services, and practices, including—
assistance with the drafting, disseminating, and implementing of legislation for family preservation and reunification and the provision of permanent parental care;
assistance with the development of systems designed to support family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care for institutionalized orphans;
assistance with the establishment of public, private, and faith- and community-based partnerships designed to support the preservation and reunification of families and permanent parental care for orphans;
assistance with the development of workforce training for governmental and nongovernmental staff working to support the preservation and reunification of families and permanent parental care for orphans; and
assistance with infrastructure development and data collection techniques necessary to—
support the biennial census required under paragraph (6)(A);
collect permanency indicators described in paragraph (6)(B);
collect the data necessary to determine to what extent countries meet the minimum standards described in section 6; and
organizing exchanges for child welfare, adoption, and other social service professionals working to support the preservation and reunification of families and permanent parental care for orphans.
Preservation of the family and permanent parental care conference
In fiscal year 2011, and every 2 years thereafter, the Secretary of State shall—
conduct a conference on best practices and successful strategies for the preservation and reunification of families and the provision of permanent parental care for orphans;
share and address key issues relative to—
the most current biennial census data collected under paragraph (6)(A);
the permanency indicator data collected under paragraph (6)(B); and
the data collected from the Global Best Practices Pilot Program under section 7(c); and
disseminate information regarding—
best practices for building country and regional capacity to decrease the number of orphans;
strategies for financially sustaining activities to support family preservation and reunification and permanent parental care;
best practices in international adoption and in preventing corruption; and
best methods and practices for assessing progress and quality for moving children into permanent parental care in a safe and timely manner.
Coordination
In general
The Office shall coordinate the foreign policy and assistance of the United States in support of—
families at risk of dissolution; and
orphans in need of permanent parental care.
Coordination between domestic and international policy
To the extent possible, the Coordinator shall work with the Secretary of Health and Human Services to maintain consistency between United States foreign and domestic policy on family preservation and reunification and permanent parental care.
Communication
In general
The Office shall build global awareness of its purpose and activities.
Web site
To carry out subparagraph (A), the Office shall maintain a Web site that includes—
a description of the global problems related to orphans and children in institutional and temporary nonfamily care;
the status of activities being carried out by the Office;
the progress made by the Office to achieve its goals;
current research, reports, policy, training opportunities, evaluation, and methodology describing best practices;
information collected by the biennial census under paragraph (6)(A);
permanency indicators collected under paragraph (6)(B);
the annual report submitted to Congress under paragraph (6)(C);
the status of site results for the study of global best practices conducted under section 7(c)(1);
requests for proposals, grant or contract awards, amounts, purposes, and lessons learned during implementation; and
a summary of the scope and progress of country projects funded by the Office.
Reports, research, and assessments
Biennial census of children without permanent parental care
In general
Not later than December 31, 2010, and every 2 years thereafter, the Office shall develop, oversee, support, and publish the results of a census of all children who live outside permanent parental care. The census shall enumerate the number of children, categorized by sex and age, who reside in—
a public or private orphanage;
a hospital or other medical institution or treatment facility;
temporary or long-term family-based foster care;
a group home;
a residential or congregational facility, regardless of the availability of treatment services;
kinship care without legal status or the presence of adult family members; or
a dormitory or other permanent or temporary living situation in which a government or nongovernmental organization places children who do not have parental care.
Census countries
The data collected under clause (i) shall include all member countries of the United Nations.
Delegation
The Coordinator may delegate the responsibility for conducting the census to a third party if—
such party has expertise in human or social services and international quantitative data collection and analysis; and
such a delegation is consistent with the purposes set forth in section 2(b).
Permanency indicators for children without permanent parental care
In general
The Office shall collect available data related to a series of policy and practice indicators on the capacity of foreign governments to offer permanent parental care as an option for orphaned children.
Data
Data collected under clause (i) shall include—
the number of families provided preservation services and the number of such families that remained intact after receiving such services;
the number of children in institutions who were reunified with their respective families;
the number of children placed in a permanent family through domestic adoption and the living situation of such children before such permanent placement;
the number of children who were placed in a permanent family through legal guardianship and their living situation before such permanent placement;
the number of children who were placed in a permanent family through international adoption and the living situation of such children before such permanent placement;
the number of children who were placed in legal or informal kinship care and their placement pre-kinship care;
the number of children who moved from temporary foster care to long-term foster care;
the number of children who reentered institutional care after moving into permanent parental care; and
the length of time children are spending in institutional care or foster care.
Delegation
The Coordinator may delegate the responsibility for collecting data on permanency indicators under this paragraph to a third party if—
the third party has expertise in human or social services and international quantitative data collection; and
such a delegation is consistent with the purposes set forth in section 2(b).
Consultation
The Coordinator may consult with representatives of the Millennium Challenge Corporation, the Department of Homeland Security, the United States Agency for International Development, the Department of Health and Human Services, the United Nations, UNICEF, the World Health Organization, and other aid- or child welfare-related networks and organizations to—
identify and expand existing reporting networks; and
refine common definitions of indicators.
United States indicators
The Secretary of Health and Human Services shall provide the Coordinator with the information required to be collected under this paragraph relating to individuals and families residing in the United States.
Report
Not later than December 31, 2011, and every 2 years thereafter, the Office shall publish a report that includes the data described in clause (ii).
Annual report to congress
Not later than September 1 of each year, the Secretary of State shall submit to Congress an annual report that includes—
a description of the global status of orphans;
a description of the activities of the Office in support of family preservation and reunification and permanent parental care for orphans;
estimates from the most recent biennial census of the number of children living without permanent parental care;
a description of the status of family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care initiatives underway in each foreign country receiving financial assistance under this Act;
a description of—
the major challenges faced by governments that are resulting in an increase in the numbers of orphans; and
barriers which are preventing governments from achieving permanent parental care for orphans;
trends in increasing or decreasing risks for orphans and families at risk of dissolution;
a listing of the governments that do not meet the minimum standards described in section 6(a);
trends toward improvement in family preservation and reunification;
trends in domestic and international adoption, foster care, and institutional care;
the most current permanency indicators described in subparagraph (B); and
movement toward implementation of permanency-related laws and conventions.
Grants
The Office shall oversee the provision of technical and financial assistance, including grants, pilot programs, and demonstrations, to governments and nongovernmental organizations to promote family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care for orphans.
Policy coordinating committee in support of orphan policy, diplomacy, and development
Establishment
The
President shall establish an interagency policy coordinating committee
(referred to in this section as the Policy Coordinating
Committee
), which shall monitor and support international efforts in
family preservation, family reunification, and permanent parental care for
orphans.
Appointment
The President shall appoint the members of the Policy Coordinating Committee, which shall include—
the Secretary of State, who shall serve as Chair;
the Administrator of the United States Agency for International Development;
the Attorney General;
the Secretary of Health and Human Services;
the Secretary of Homeland Security; and
any other Government official appointed by the President.
Activities of committee
The Policy Coordinating Committee shall provide advice to the Office for Orphan Policy Diplomacy and Development regarding—
the development of a comprehensive global strategy that is consistent with the minimum standards described in section 103(a);
financial support of programs that assist countries in developing child welfare systems that—
preserve and reunify families; and
provide permanent parental care for orphans.
advocacy efforts with governments, nongovernmental organizations, and other entities to advance the purposes set forth in section 2(b); and
the collection of data through significant research on family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care methods for orphans.
Working groups
Members of the Policy Coordinating Committee may create small working groups within their respective agencies to support and advise their work on behalf of the Policy Coordinating Committee.
Minimum standards for the provision of permanent parental care
Minimum standards
A country meets the minimum standards for the provision of permanent parental care by a partner country if—
the government of the country has laws, practices, and judicial standards that—
protect children from abuse and neglect;
are aimed at reducing the number of abandoned children;
are aimed at preserving families at risk of dissolution;
are aimed at safely and appropriately reunifying orphans and institutionalized children with their families;
promote legal guardianship and kinship care;
promote domestic adoption;
allow for international adoption; and
promote the physical and emotional well-being and protection of children while they are waiting for reunification or placement with a permanent family;
the government of the country is—
keeping a significant percentage of families at risk of dissolution intact;
reuniting a significant percentage of orphans and institutionalized children with biological families and relatives; and
moving a significant percentage of orphans into permanent parental care in situations in which the orphans cannot be reunified with their families; and
the numbers of children aging out of institutions or foster care in such country is decreasing by a significant percentage each year.
Criteria
A country is eligible for assistance from the Office for Orphan Policy Diplomacy and Development under this Act if the government of the country—
publicly acknowledges the need for family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care for orphans; and
demonstrates a commitment to develop improved laws, policies, infrastructure, and training programs to preserve and reunify families and provide permanent parental care for orphans by—
developing formal strategic plans to develop laws and infrastructure to address shortcomings related to meeting the minimum standards described in subsection (a);
allocating resources to study the issues described in subparagraph (A); or
expending or setting aside sufficient funds to help build child welfare and judicial infrastructure and enact laws to address shortcomings related to meeting such minimum standards.
Grant, pilot, and development programs
Assistance to foreign governments
Chapter 1 of part I of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961 (22 U.S.C. 2151 et seq.) is amended—
by redesignating section 135, as added by section 5(a) of Public Law 109–121, as section 137; and
by inserting after section 135, as added by section 3 of Public Law 109–95, the following:
Assistance to foreign governments
Assistance To meet minimum standards
The President is authorized to provide assistance to foreign countries directly, or through nongovernmental and multilateral organizations, for programs, projects, and activities designed to assist the country to meet the minimum standards described in section 6(a) of the Families for Orphans Act of 2009.
Assistance to foreign governments that meet minimum standards
In general
The President is authorized to provide assistance, including trade and debt relief, to any foreign country that demonstrates success in meeting the majority of the minimum standards and other goals described in paragraph (2).
Plan
The government of a country desiring assistance under this subsection shall demonstrate a commitment to meeting the minimum standards described in section 6(a) of the Families for Orphans Act of 2009 by independently, or with assistance from the Office for Orphan Policy Diplomacy and Development, developing—
a detailed, long-term strategic plan for meeting such minimum standards and related long-range goals; and
a 1-year or 2-year operational plan that describes the immediate steps that the foreign government will take toward meeting such minimum standards.
.
Assistance in support of family preservation and permanent parental care for orphans
In general
The Secretary of State is authorized to award grants to nongovernmental agencies working to promote permanent parental care for orphans, in accordance with the results of the global best practices study conducted under subsection (c).
Use of funds
Grants received under this subsection may be used to—
improve public policy in support of the preservation and reunification of families and permanent parental care for orphans;
reduce the number of children abandoned;
reduce the number of families at risk of dissolution;
increase the number of children reunified with their parents;
increase the number of children obtaining legal guardianship and kinship care;
increase the number of children placed for adoption domestically;
support international adoption for children who cannot be adopted domestically, or reunified with their biological parents;
draft laws and develop systems designed to promote ethical, evidence-based practice in international adoption;
increase the level of expertise and understanding of foreign governments working to preserve and reunify families and promote permanent parental care for orphans;
create and support connections with caring, committed adults to older children at risk of, or in the process of, aging out of institutional care;
develop mentoring, visitation, and foster adopt programs aimed at recruiting a larger number of individuals willing to provide permanent parental care for orphans;
increase adoption support services; and
create and improve child welfare and judicial infrastructures, which strengthen and support permanent family care for orphans.
Eligibility criteria
To the extent possible, grants shall be awarded under this subsection to organizations that have demonstrated—
experience in the area of child welfare and judicial policy, family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care for orphans;
success in working with the in-country governmental agencies responsible for care of children; and
adherence to the child welfare laws of the foreign government in which such organizations are located.
Global best practices
Study on global best practices
In general
Not later than 90 days after the date of the enactment of this Act, the Secretary of State shall initiate a study to identify global best practices for—
preserving and reunifying families; and
providing permanent parental care for orphans.
Identification of factors
In conducting the study under subparagraph (A), the Secretary shall identify—
evidence-based programs that are demonstrated to provide permanent parental care in a timely manner;
policies and practices that result in increased deinstitutionalization of children;
laws of other countries that require and support permanent parental care;
factors that decrease the dissolution of families; and
best practices for promoting ethical international adoption practices.
Report
Not later than 1 year after initiating the study under this paragraph, the Secretary shall publish a report on the best practices identified in the study.
Use of study results
The Secretary shall use the results of the study conducted under this paragraph to guide and inform—
the award of all grants under this Act; and
all activities in the global best practices pilot program carried out under paragraph (2).
Global best practices pilot program
In general
Upon completing the study described in paragraph (1), the Secretary of State shall establish and carry out a global best practices pilot program.
Purposes
The purposes of the program established pursuant to subparagraph (A) shall be to—
demonstrate how research-based policies and programs to provide orphans with permanent parental care can be successfully implemented;
establish model programs that, once tested for effectiveness, will be available, replicable, and adaptable on a global basis;
identify a comprehensive series of interventions, which result in family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care for orphans; and
determine which in-country factors enhance or negate efforts to achieve family preservation, reunification, and permanent parental care for orphans.
Selection of sites
Number of sites
In carrying out the pilot program established under this paragraph, the Secretary of State shall select and establish not fewer than 5 sites, each of which shall be located in a different region of the world.
Priorities
In selecting sites under clause (i), the Secretary shall consider—
cultural, geographic, and economic diversity of countries included in the region;
whether governments within the region have sufficient infrastructure and capacity to support the pilot program; and
the incidence of abandoned children and children in institutional care in the region and culture.
Delegation
The Coordinator for Orphan Policy Diplomacy and Development may delegate implementation of the pilot program under this paragraph to 1 or more organizations that have experience in the use of evidence-based programs to promote family preservation, reunification, or permanent parental care for orphans.
Annual report
Not later than 1 year after the date on which the first pilot program is established under this paragraph, and each subsequent year, the Coordinator shall publish a report on the status of, and lessons learned in, the pilot program.
Authorization of appropriations
Operations
There are authorized to be appropriated for the administrative costs associated with carrying out the duties of the Office for Orphan Policy Diplomacy and Development—
$3,000,000 for fiscal year 2010; and
such sums as may be necessary for each subsequent fiscal year.
Assistance to foreign governments
There are authorized to be appropriated for assistance to foreign governments under section 136 of the Foreign Assistance Act of 1961—
$5,000,000 for fiscal year 2010; and
such sums as may be necessary for each subsequent fiscal year.
Grants to support permanent parental care
There is authorized to be appropriated for grants under section 7(b)—
$5,000,000 for fiscal year 2010; and
such sums as may be necessary for each subsequent fiscal year.
Global best practices pilot program
There are authorized to be appropriated to the Secretary of State to carry out section 7(c)—
$3,000,000 for fiscal year 2010; and
such sums as may be necessary for each subsequent fiscal year.