Mr. Speaker, I thank my good friend, the distinguished majority leader, Mr. Scalise, for yielding. Mr. Speaker, for the purpose of debate only, I yield the customary 30 minutes to the gentleman from…
Mr. Speaker, I thank my good friend, the distinguished majority leader, Mr. Scalise, for yielding.
Mr. Speaker, for the purpose of debate only, I yield the customary 30 minutes to the gentleman from Massachusetts (Mr. McGovern), my good friend, pending which I yield myself such time as I may consume. During consideration of this resolution, all time is yielded for the purpose of debate only.
General Leave
Mr. Speaker, I ask unanimous consent that all Members may have 5 legislative days in which to revise and extend their remarks.
Mr. Speaker, I include in the Record the section-by-section analysis of the resolution.
H. Res. 5
Adopting the Rules for the 118th Congress
Section-by-Section Analysis
Section 1. Adoption of the Rules of the One Hundred
Seventeenth Congress.
This section provides that the Rules of the 117th Congress
are the Rules of the 118th Congress, except for the
amendments contained in section 2 of the resolution and
orders contained in the resolution.
Section 2. Changes to the Standing Rules.
Initiatives to Reduce Spending and Improve Accountability.
Subsection (a)(l) replaces current ``pay-as-you-go''
requirements with ``cut-as-you-go'' requirements. The
provision prohibits consideration of a bill, joint
resolution, conference report, or amendment that has the net
effect of increasing mandatory spending within a five-year or
ten-year budget window. This provision continues the current
practice of counting multiple measures considered pursuant to
a special order of business which directs the Clerk to
engross the measures together after passage for purposes of
compliance with the rule and provides a mechanism for
addressing ``emergency'' designations.
Subsection (a)(2) strikes the ``Gephardt rule'' that
provides for the automatic engrossment and transmittal to the
Senate of a joint resolution changing the public debt limit,
upon the adoption by the House of a concurrent resolution on
the budget resolution, thereby avoiding a separate vote in
the House on the public debt limit legislation.
Subsection (a)(3) restores a point of order against net
increase in budget authority for amendments to general
appropriations bills.
Subsection (a)(4) restores a point of order against budget
reconciliation directives that increase net direct spending.
Increased Threshold for Tax Rate Increases. Subsection (b)
restores a requirement for a three-fifths supermajority vote
on tax rate increases.
Two Minute Votes. Subsection (c) provides that the Speaker
can reduce vote times in the House to not less than two
minutes on any question that follows another electronic vote.
The subsection also states that to the maximum extent
practicable, advance notice will be given when reduced voting
times are expected in a voting series.
Modifications to Calendar Wednesday. Subsection (d)
modifies the notice requirement to use Calendar Wednesday to
conform with the 72-hour notice requirement prior to
consideration of legislation.
Committee Authorization and Oversight Plans. Subsection (e)
restores the requirement that each standing committee (except
the Committees on Appropriations, Ethics, and Rules) vote to
adopt an authorization and oversight plan, which must be
submitted to the Committees on Oversight and Accountability
and House Administration no later than March 1 of the first
session of a Congress. The plan must include a list of
unauthorized programs and agencies within the committee's
jurisdiction that have received funding in the prior fiscal
year, or in the case of a permanent authorization, have not
received a comprehensive review by the committee in the prior
three Congresses. The subsection requires committees to
describe each program or agency that is intended to be
authorized in the current Congress or next Congress, and a
description of oversight to support reauthorization in the
current Congress. The subsection also requires the
plan include any recommendations for moving such programs or
agencies from mandatory to discretionary funding. When
developing these plans, committee chairs must coordinate with
other committees of jurisdiction to ensure that programs and
agencies are subject to routine authorization efforts.
The subsection also provides that committee authorization
and oversight plans may make recommendations to consolidate
or terminate duplicative or unnecessary programs and
agencies. Committees may make recommendations for changes to
existing law to address Federal rules, regulations, statutes,
and court decisions related to programs that are inconsistent
with Congress' Article I authorities, as well as provide a
description of other oversight activities that may be
necessary.
The subsection also requires the Committee on Oversight and
Accountability to report to the House no later than April 15
the authorization and oversight plans submitted by committees
together with any recommendations it may make to ensure
effective coordination of the plans.
Cost Estimates for Major Legislation to Include
Macroeconomic Effects. Subsection (f) restores the
requirement that the Congressional Budget Office and Joint
Committee on Taxation, to the extent practicable, incorporate
the macroeconomic effects of major legislation into the
official cost estimates used for enforcing the budget
resolution and other rules of the House. The subsection
requires, to the extent practicable, a qualitative assessment
of the long-term budgetary and macroeconomic effects of major
legislation, which is defined to cover legislation that
causes a gross budgetary effect in any fiscal year covered by
the budget resolution that is equal to or greater than 0.25
percent of the projected GDP for that year. This subsection
also allows the chair of the Committee on the Budget, or in
the case of revenue legislation the House member serving
as the Chair or Vice Chair of the Joint Committee on
Taxation, to designate major legislation for purposes of
this rule.
Ethics Reform. Subsection (g) directs the Committee on
Ethics to adopt rules which provide for a process to receive
complaints directly from the public.
Empaneling Investigative Subcommittee of the Committee on
Ethics. Subsection (h) codifies House Resolution 451, 110th
Congress, directing the Committee on Ethics to empanel an
investigative subcommittee or issue a report within 30 days
of the date a Member, Delegate, or the Resident Commissioner
is indicted, or criminal charges are filed.
Treatment of Evidence in Committee and Subcommittee
Investigations. Subsection (i) eliminates a requirement that
the Committee on Ethics adopt a rule allowing the use during
an ethics investigation of evidence presented in a related
criminal case where the respondent was convicted because this
is already contained in the committee rules of the Committee
on Ethics.
Designating Committee on Oversight and Accountability.
Subsection (j) redesignates the Committee on Oversight and
Reform as the Committee on Oversight and Accountability.
Designating Committee on Education and the Workforce.
Subsection (k) redesignates the Committee on Education and
Labor as the Committee on Education and the Workforce.
Subcommittees of Committee on Agriculture. Subsection (1)
permits the Committee on Agriculture to have six
subcommittees, codifying a separate order in effect since the
114th Congress.
Cybersecurity. Subsection (m) modifies the jurisdiction of
the Committee on Homeland Security to include functions of
the Department of Homeland Security related to cybersecurity.
Committees currently holding jurisdiction over cybersecurity
functions of DHS will retain a shared jurisdictional interest
in such functions.
Scope of Authority to Act in Continuing Litigation Matters.
Subsection (n) eliminates ``including, but not limited to,
the issuance of subpoenas'' in the description of authority
to act as successor-in-interest in continuing litigation
matters, such language being superfluous.
Record Votes on Measures Reported by the Committee on
Rules. Subsection (o) requires reports from the Committee on
Rules to include a depiction of recorded votes.
Access to the Hall of the House. Subsection (p) strikes
language providing Governors of Territories and the Mayor of
the District of Columbia access to the Hall of the House.
Resolution Declaring the Office of Speaker Vacant.
Subsection (q) strikes language from rule IX to allow any
member to offer a privileged resolution declaring the Office
of Speaker vacant.
Section 3. Separate Orders.
Holman Rule. Subsection (a) reinstates the ``Holman Rule''
which allows amendments to appropriations legislation that
would reduce the salary of or fire specific federal
employees, or cut a specific program.
Restoring Legislative Branch Accountability. Subsection (b)
states regulations adopted pursuant to House Resolution 1096,
117th Congress will have no force or effect in the 118th
Congress.
Requirement with Respect to Single Subject Bill. Subsection
(c) provides that, effective February 1, 2023, a bill or
joint resolution may not be introduced unless the sponsor
submits a statement setting forth the single subject of the
bill or joint resolution. This statement must be included
with the statement required by clause 7(c) of rule XII
(Constitutional Authority Statements). A statement for any
bill or joint resolution introduced prior to the effective
date shall, to the extent practicable, be submitted by the
sponsor prior to committee or House consideration.
Question of Consideration for Germanenes. Subsection (d)
establishes a question of consideration on a special rule
that waives germaneness for an amendment. The question of
consideration is debatable for 20 minutes and is not subject
to any intervening motion.
Budget Matter. Subsection (e)(l)(A) provides the authority
for the chair of the Committee on the Budget to file
allocations, aggregates, and other appropriate budgetary
levels for the purpose of enforcing provisions of the
Congressional Budget Act of 1974. Additionally, this
subsection states that the provisions of S. Con. Res. 14,
117th Congress shall have no force or effect.
Subsection (e)(l)(B) provides adjustment authority to the
chair of the Committee on the Budget for a bill, joint
resolution, amendment thereto, or conference report thereon
if the measure does not increase direct spending over five
or ten years. It additionally provides adjustment
authority to the chair of the Committee on the Budget to
take into account the most recent baseline published by
the Congressional Budget Office.
Subsection (e)(1)(C) allows the Majority Leader or his
designee, should the chair of the Committee on the Budget not
yet be elected, to file statements permitted under
subsections (f)(1)(A) and (f)(1)(B).
Subsection (e)(1)(D) allows the chair of the Committee on
the Budget (or the Majority Leader or his designee, should
the chair not yet be elected) to adjust an estimate under
clause 4 of rule XXIX to exempt the budgetary effects of
measures to protect taxpayers with taxable incomes below
$400,000 from an increase in audits above the most recent tax
year from the Internal Revenue Service.
Subsection (e)(2) establishes a point of order against
consideration of a bill or joint resolution reported by a
committee (other than the Committee on Appropriations) or an
amendment thereto, or a conference report thereon, which has
the net effect of increasing direct spending in excess of
$2,500,000,000 for any of the four consecutive 10 fiscal year
periods beginning with the first fiscal year that is 10
fiscal years after the current fiscal year. The levels of net
increases in direct spending shall be determined based on
estimates provided by the chair of the Committee on the
Budget.
Subsection (e)(3) requires the Congressional Budget Office
on any legislation that shows changes in mandatory spending
which cause a gross budgetary effect in any fiscal year
covered by the budget resolution that is equal to or greater
than 0.25 percent of the projected GDP for the current fiscal
year, to the extent practicable, to provide an estimate of
the inflationary impacts of that legislation. This subsection
also allows the chair of the Committee on the Budget to
designate major legislation for purposes of this order.
Subsection (e)(4) requires the Congressional Budget Office
on any legislation impacting either the Medicare Part A trust
fund or OASDI trust fund that causes a gross budgetary effect
in any fiscal year covered by the budget resolution that is
equal to or greater than 0.25 percent of the projected GDP
for the current fiscal year, to the extent practicable, to
display: (1) the impact of legislation on the Medicare Part A
trust fund's unfunded liabilities over a 25-year projection,
solvency projections, and the net present value of those
liabilities; and (2) the impact on the OASDI trust fund's
unfunded liabilities over a 75-year projection, solvency
projections, and the net present value of those liabilities.
This subsection also allows the chair of the Committee on the
Budget to designate major legislation for purposes of this
order.
Spending Reduction Amendments in Appropriations Bills.
Subsection (f) provides for spending reduction account
transfer amendments and requires a spending reduction account
section to be included in all general appropriations bills.
Scoring Conveyances of Federal Land. Subsection (g)
reinstates the separate order from the 115th Congress
providing that any provision in a bill, joint resolution,
amendment, or conference report requiring or authorizing a
conveyance of federal land to a State, local government, or
tribal entity, shall not be considered as providing new
budget authority, decreasing revenues, increasing mandatory
spending, or increasing outlays.
Member Day Hearing Requirement. Subsection (h) modifies the
Member Day hearing requirement to only occur at the full
committee level. Each standing committee (other than the
Committee on Ethics) must hold a Member Day Hearing during
the first session of the 118th Congress to receive testimony
from Members, Delegates, and the Resident Commissioner on
proposed legislation within its jurisdiction. The subsection
permits the Committee on Rules to hold its Member Day Hearing
during the second session to receive testimony on proposed
changes to the standing rules for the next Congress.
Information to Committees of Congress on Request.
Subsection (i) requires that the chair of the Committee on
Oversight and Accountability be included as one of the seven
members of the committee making any request of an Executive
agency pursuant to section 2954 of title 5, United States
Code.
Remote Appearance of Witnesses. Subsection (j) provides
limited authorization to a chair
of a committee to allow witnesses to appear remotely at
committee and subcommittee proceedings. This subsection
applies only to witnesses appearing in a non-governmental
capacity and in accordance with regulations issued by the
chair of the Committee on Rules and printed in the
Congressional Record.
Deposition Authority. Subsection (k) provides the Permanent
Select Committee on Intelligence and each standing committee
of the 118th Congress (except for the Committee on Rules) the
authority to order the taking of a deposition by a member or
counsel of such committee and limits persons who can attend
depositions to members, committee staff, an official
reporter, the witness, and up to two, personal,
nongovernmental attorneys. Depositions taken under this
authority are subject to regulations issued by the chair of
the Committee on Rules and printed in the Congressional
Record.
Broadening Availability and Utility of Legislative
Documents in Machine-Readable Formats. Subsection (l)
instructs the Committee on House Administration, the Clerk,
an other officers and officials to advance
government transparency by continuing efforts to publish
documents of the House in machinereadable formats and
broaden their utility by enabling all House staff to
create comparative prints.
Improving the Committee Electronic Document Repository.
Subsection (m) directs the Clerk, the Committee on House
Administration, and other officers and officials to continue
to improve the existing electronic document repository
operated by the Clerk for use by committees. Such
improvements are intended to increase public availability and
identification of legislative information produced by House
committees, including votes, amendments, and witness
disclosure forms.
Providing for Transparency with Respect to Memorials
Submitted Pursuant to Article V of the Constitution of the
United States. Subsection (n) carries forward provisions that
clarify the procedures of the House regarding the receipt of
Article V memorials from the States by directing the Clerk to
make each memorial, designated by the chair of the Committee
on the Judiciary, electronically available, organized by
State of origin and year of receipt, and indicate whether the
memorial was designated as an application or rescission.
In carrying out this subsection, it is expected that the
chair of the Committee on the Judiciary will be solely
charged with determining whether a memorial purports to be an
application of the legislature of a state calling for a
constitutional convention or rescission of prior
applications. The Clerk's role will be entirely
administrative. The chair of the Committee on the Judiciary
will only designate memorials from state legislatures (and
not petitions from individuals or other parties), as it is
only state legislatures that are contemplated under Article V
of the Constitution.
In submitting each memorial to the Clerk, the chair of the
Committee on the Judiciary will include a transmission letter
that indicates it has been designated under this subsection.
The Clerk will make publicly available the memorial and the
transmission letter from the chair. Ancillary documentation
from the state or other parties is not expected to be
publicized.
War Powers Resolution. Subsection (o) continues a separate
order from the 117th Congress expressly providing that any
motion to discharge a measure introduced pursuant to section
6 or section 7 of the War Powers Resolution is not subject to
a motion to table.
Further Expenses for Resolving Contested Elections.
Subsection (p) authorizes such sums as may be necessary for
the Committee on House Administration to resolve contested
elections. Funds shall be available for expenses incurred
between January 3, 2023, and January 3, 2024. Amounts made
available under this subsection shall be expended in
accordance with regulations prescribed by the Committee on
House Administration.
Ethics Reform. Subsection (q) directs the Speaker to
establish a bipartisan task force to conduct a comprehensive
review of House ethics rules and regulations. The task force
is directed to submit a report to the Speaker, Majority
Leader, Minority Leader, and chair and ranking minority
members of the Committees on Ethics and Rules.
Exercise Facilities for Former Members. Subsection (r)
continues the prohibition on access to any exercise facility
that is made available exclusively to Members, Delegates, the
Resident Commissioner, former Members, former Delegates,
former Resident Commissioners, officers, and former officers
of the House and their spouses to any former Member, former
Delegate, former Resident Commissioner, former officer, or
spouse who is a lobbyist registered under the Lobbying
Disclosure Act of 1995 or any successor statute, or who is an
agent of a foreign principal as defined in clause 5 of rule
Mr. Speaker, I yield 1 minute to the gentleman from Louisiana (Mr. Scalise), my good friend and the majority leader.
Mr. Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may consume.
I begin by thanking my good friend from Massachusetts for his leadership of the Rules Committee over the last 4 years. While we certainly haven't always agreed, we have tried to always be agreeable while working with one another. I certainly associate myself with his remarks about the terrific work of the staff on both sides of the aisle for helping us facilitate the operation of the House over that 4-year period. I look forward again to working with my friend in the years ahead.
Mr. Speaker, I rise today to offer the rules resolution that will govern the House during the 118th Congress.
Determining the rules we will follow is one of the first and most consequential decisions we must make as a body at the beginning of each Congress. In many ways, the Rules of the House of Representatives serve to demonstrate where our priorities and values lie as an institution.
Make no mistake, the priorities of the new Republican majority are fully on display in this resolution.
First and foremost, Mr. Speaker, we are taking action to reopen the people's House and ensure that we, the people's elected servants, are here in Washington, D.C., doing our jobs.
For far too long, the House allowed Members to do their jobs from home without ever setting foot in Washington. What started out as a pandemic accommodation lasted far longer than necessary, but today, even President Biden admits that the pandemic is over.
It is time for the House of Representatives to return to our normal operating procedures, and it is time for the Members of Congress to actually show up to work. Today's rules package eliminates proxy voting and puts an end to remote committee proceedings.
We restore the requirement for committees to establish plans for how they will conduct much-needed oversight. Republicans have robust plans to ensure that we will hold the Biden administration accountable for its actions, but being a counterbalance to the administration will not stop there. With today's rules package, we will also establish a new select subcommittee, modeled on the Church Committee, to investigate the radical left's weaponization of the Federal Government in recent years.
We will also modify the jurisdiction of the Select Subcommittee on the Coronavirus Pandemic to ensure we investigate the origins of the virus and finally look into the financial and societal impacts of shutdowns.
We will establish a Select Committee on Strategic Competition Between the United States and the Chinese Communist Party to respond to threats posed by the CCP, ensure economic competitiveness for America, and protect human rights.
Other important changes in this resolution are those that are designed to address our out-of-control spending problem, which the former majority made vastly worse last Congress. In fact, when Democrats were in control of this Chamber, they spent so much money through partisan bills that they managed to drive this country into an inflationary crisis. Those aren't my words; those are the words of former Clinton Treasury Secretary Larry Summers.
The American people elected Republicans to get our fiscal house in order, and get our fiscal house in order we will. That starts with making key changes to House rules to ensure we will instill some fiscal sanity in Congress. These changes reflect a return to budgetary rules that were in place for over a decade before Democrats removed them.
We will restore the CutGo rule, which requires us to offset any increase in mandatory spending with a corresponding cut in mandatory spending. No more will the House be able to use budget gimmicks and tricks to pretend increases in mandatory spending are paid for when they actually are not.
We will restore a requirement for a three-fifths majority to approve any tax rate increase. If this rule had been in place, the House would not have passed the massive tax increases the Democrats included in last year's reconciliation bill.
We will eliminate the so-called Gephardt rule, which allows the House to automatically suspend the debt ceiling upon passage of a budget resolution. Just as the American people have to live within their means, so, too, should the Federal Government.
Automatically suspending the debt limit may be the easy and expedient way, but on a matter as important as the national debt limit, what is easy and expedient is hardly appropriate. The American people expect us to make a decision on the national debt limit only after full and fair consideration and debate in the House. That starts with ensuring it will receive a separate, standalone vote on the floor.
Finally, we will remove the rule that allowed Democrats to simply ignore budget estimates for bills dealing with the COVID pandemic or climate change. Although it may sound controversial to my friends on the other side of the aisle, Republicans cannot and will not thrust our heads in the sand and ignore the effects of out-of-control Federal spending.
Mr. Speaker, I could go on and on, but on the whole, I am very proud of today's rule package. It reflects Republican priorities and the priorities of the voters who elected us. It reopens this institution and ensures that all Members will be in Washington to do their work, as our constituents expect. It ensures that we will hold the Biden administration and the Chinese Communist Party accountable. It ensures that we will get our fiscal house in order.
Mr. Speaker, I urge all Members to support the rules package, and I reserve the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gentleman from Texas (Mr. Burgess), my very good friend, a member of both the Rules Committee and the Energy and Commerce Committee.
Mr. Speaker, I yield 3 minutes to the distinguished gentlewoman from Minnesota (Mrs. Fischbach), my colleague on the Rules Committee.
Mr. Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the gentleman from Virginia (Mr. Griffith), my very good friend who had so much to do with some of the extraordinary changes in this rules package.
Mr. Speaker, I yield an additional 30 seconds to the gentleman from Virginia.
Mr. Speaker, I yield 3 minutes to the distinguished gentleman from South Dakota (Mr. Johnson), my good friend.
Mr. Speaker, I yield 2 minutes to the distinguished gentleman from South Carolina (Mr. Duncan).
Mr. Speaker, I yield 3 minutes to the distinguished gentlewoman from Florida (Mrs. Cammack).
Mr. Speaker, I yield 4 minutes to the distinguished gentleman from Texas (Mr. Roy).
Mr. Speaker, I yield 1\1/2\ minutes to the distinguished gentleman from Georgia (Mr. Clyde).
Mr. Speaker, I yield 1 minute to the gentleman from South Carolina (Mr. Norman).
Mr. Speaker, I ask unanimous consent that the Speaker be authorized to postpone the vote on ordering the previous question on House Resolution 5 to a designated time later today.
Mr. Speaker, I ask unanimous consent that the Chair may reduce to 5 minutes the minimum time for electronic voting on any question relating to House Resolution 5 that follows a 15-minute vote.
Mr. Speaker, I reserve the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, I continue to reserve the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, I yield 1 minute to the distinguished gentleman from Arkansas (Mr. Hill), my good friend.
Mr. Speaker, I am prepared to close whenever my friend is.
Mr. Speaker, I yield myself the balance of my time.
In closing, I urge all my colleagues to support this resolution establishing the rules of the 118th Congress. The changes we are proposing today will ensure that the institution is set on a path of success for the new Congress.
They will ensure that Members return to Washington and do their work here.
They will set up an institution to hold the Biden administration accountable.
They will put in place budgetary rules designed to prevent the kind of reckless spending spree Democrats recently engaged in.
I urge all Members to vote ``yes'' on the previous question and ``yes'' on the rule.
Mr. Speaker, I yield back the balance of my time, and I move the previous question on the resolution.