Mr. Speaker, I would like to include in the Record a letter from the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights that indicates the strong opposition to the SAVE Act of 146 local, state, and national organizations. May 16, 2024. Hon.…
Mr. Speaker, I would like to include in the Record a letter from the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights that indicates the strong opposition to the SAVE Act of 146 local, state, and national organizations.
May 16, 2024.
Hon. Bryan Steil,
Chair, Committee on House Administration, Washington, DC.
Hon. Joe Morelle,
Ranking Member, Committee on House Administration,
Washington, DC.
Dear Chair Steil and Ranking Member Morelle: On behalf of
the Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights, a
coalition of national organizations committed to promoting
and protecting the civil and human rights of all persons in
the United States, the Declaration for American Democracy, a
coalition of local, state, and national organizations working
to strengthen U.S. democracy; and the undersigned 123
organizations, we write in strong opposition to the Safeguard
American Voter Eligibility (SAVE) Act.
Congress has a pivotal constitutional responsibility to
safeguard free and fair elections and to ensure all Americans
have the freedom to vote. The SAVE Act represents a dangerous
departure from fulfilling this vital duty. The bill's
requirement of documentary proof of American citizenship to
register to vote in federal elections is wholly based on
falsehoods and, even worse, seeks to promote fear-mongering
and divisive rhetoric. Instead of proceeding with this
legislation, Congress should take actions that will help
voters and promote democracy such as passing legislation that
will strengthen protections against discrimination in voting
and expand access to the ballot for all communities.
The SAVE Act is both unnecessary and dangerous. Our
electoral system already deploys processes to ensure that our
elections are secure and that only eligible voters are
participating in our democracy. Voters in every state are
already required to affirm or verify their citizenship status
when registering to vote. State election officials already
have in place existing systems to verify an individual's
voter eligibility and ensure voter rolls are accurate.
Moreover, federal law already prohibits noncitizens from
voting in federal elections. Every single state bans
noncitizens from voting in state elections. These protections
have proven very effective, given that there is simply no
evidence of widespread noncitizen voting in elections.
Indeed, it defies logic that non-U.S. citizens would risk
their immigration status, the potential of criminal
prosecution, future opportunity for naturalization, and
freedom for themselves and their families by unlawfully
committing an affirmative act to vote in an election in which
they are prohibited from participating. The penalties for
registering or voting as a non-U.S. citizen include
imprisonment or deportation. The risks for any non-U.S.
citizen to vote in a federal election are serious and steep,
and our laws already effectively prevent significant unlawful
voter registration and voting.
Introduction and advancement of this bill is the most
recent example of what has been a string of recent efforts to
make voter registration and voting more difficult,
particularly for voters of color. False claims of non-citizen
voting have been disingenuously used to enact more onerous
voter identification requirements, limitations on voter
assistance in languages other than English, and attempts to
spread misinformation about voting. This legislation seeks to
intimidate members of immigrant communities and communities
of color from exercising their lawful right to vote. It also
would make it harder for voters of color and naturalized
citizens to register to vote and would prevent their full
participation in democracy. These are already communities who
are unfairly targeted by anti-immigrant policies at the
federal, state, and local level. Congress should be doing
everything possible to encourage and promote the political
participation of these citizens, rather than seeking to
diminish it through threats and fear tactics.
Legislation like the SAVE Act is intended to elicit
irrational fear of the growing number of citizens of color.
Congress should instead act to ensure that every eligible
U.S. citizen has the freedom to vote unimpeded by
discriminatory rules rooted in fear and division. We urge you
to instead focus on passing real pro-voter reforms to ensure
that everyone can fully participate in our democracy. If you
have any questions, please contact Leslie Proll, senior
director of the voting rights program at The Leadership
Conference, at proll@civilrights.org.
Sincerely,
The Leadership Conference on Civil and Human Rights;
Declaration for American Democracy; 18by Vote; Accountable
US; Advancement Project; AFT; All About The Ballots; All On
The Line; All Voting Is Local Action; America's Voice;
American Association of People with Disabilities (AAPD);
American Association of University Women (AAUW); American
Civil Liberties Union; American Federation of State County
and Municipal Employees; Arab American Institute (AAI); Asian
American Legal Defense and Education Fund (AALDEF); Asian
Americans Advancing Justice--AAJC; Asian and Pacific Islander
American Vote (APIA Vote); Autistic Self Advocacy Network.
Baltimore County Progressive Democrats Club; Black Voters
Matter Fund; Brennan Center for Justice; Campaign Legal
Center; Carolina Jews for Justice; Center for Common Ground;
Center for Living & Working, Inc.; Center for Popular
Democracy; Chicago Survivors; Chispa LCV; CivicGeorgia; Clean
Elections Texas; Coalition on Human Needs; Common Cause;
Common Defense; Communications Workers of America; Courage
for America; Defend Democracy; DemCast USA; Democracy 21.
Democracy Maine; Democracy Matters; Democracy SENTRY;
Demos; Detroit Disability Power; End Citizens United // Let
America Vote Action Fund; Fair Elections Center; Faith
Commons; Faith in Public Life Action; Fix Democracy First;
FLIC Votes; Free Speech For People; Georgia Coalition for the
Peoples Agenda; Get Money Out--Maryland; Government
Information Watch; Greenpeace USA; HeadCount; Helping Hands
Outreach Services of Mississippi; Hip Hop Caucus; Indivisible
Santa Fe.
Interfaith Alliance; Japanese American Citizens League;
JustLeadership USA; LDF; League of Conservation Voters;
League of Women Voters of the United States; MALDEF; Memphis
APRI; Missouri Voter Protection Coalition; MomsRising;
MoveOn; Muslims for Community, Action and Support (MCAS);
N.C. For the People Action; NALEO Educational Fund; National
Action Network; National Asian Pacific American Bar
Association (NAPABA); National Association of Councils on
Developmental Disabilities; National Association of Social
Workers; National Community Action Partnership; National
Council of Jewish Women.
National Disability Rights Network (NDRN); National
Education Association; National Employment Law Project;
National Network for Arab American Communities (NNAAC);
National Urban League; Native American Rights Fund; NETWORK
Lobby for Catholic Social Justice; New Georgia Project Action
Fund; Out of Many 1 Advocacy; People For the American Way;
People Power United; Pride at Work; Project On Government
Oversight; Protect Democracy; Public Citizen; RepresentUs;
RespectAbility; Safer Country; Scrutineers; Secure Elections
Network; Southern Poverty Law Center Action Fund.
Stand UP Alaska; Stand Up America; State Voices; Storied
Analytics LLC; The National Vote; The Workers Circle;
Transformative Justice Coalition; Transparency International
U.S.; Un-PAC; UnidosUS; Unitarian Universalists for Social
Justice; United Church of Christ; Vote.org; Voter
Participation Center; Voters Rights and Protection Taskforce;
Voto Latino; WALKING TO FIX OUR DEMOCRACY; We Are All
America; Westchester for Change; Wind of the Spirit Immigrant
Resource Center; Wisconsin Faith Voices for Justice; Women's
March; WV Citizen Action; WV FREE (West Virginia Focus:
Reproductive Education and Equity); ZERO TO THREE.