American Involvement In Afghanistan
Madam Speaker, today during the debate about Afghanistan, I joined Mr. Kucinich and several others in our concerns about Afghanistan, and I wanted to further read to the House. I had used a Marine Times article that has a photograph of a…
Madam Speaker, today during the debate about Afghanistan, I joined Mr. Kucinich and several others in our concerns about Afghanistan, and I wanted to further read to the House. I had used a Marine Times article that has a photograph of a marine who is retired now and his son, Joshua, who was killed in Afghanistan. The article says ``Caution Killed My Son. Marine Families Blast Suicidal Tactics in Afghanistan.''
In addition to this article about his son and the tighter rules of engagement, ``families voice outrage over new restrictions in Afghanistan,'' they also have an article about four marines who were killed that asked the Army to give them cover. The Army didn't say ``no''; they just didn't even respond.
The rules of engagement are so different for our troops that I think at some point in time we in the Congress, particularly on the Armed Services Committee, I am going to ask for a hearing about the rules of engagement.
I want to explain and then read a couple of comments from the father which was in this article, Sergeant Bernard, retired Marine, whose son Joshua was killed. What had happened was the marines had been in a firefight. Then there was an Afghan that came to the marines and said, Listen, there are other Taliban enemy down the road, and if you follow me, I will show you where they are located.
This is where I want to pick up the story by the father's writing. He said, When the ambush began, the tipster could not be found, and the interpreter took cover, raising questions in Bernard's mind about whether they led the Marines into a trap. There's no question they did. I further quote Sergeant Bernard, who's retired now: ``Call me cynical if you want, but some rogue element led them there. The bottom line is both of those guys were gone. It's just another indication of how this counterinsurgency strategy can't work.''
I further want to read: ``In an October 13 letter to Collins, Mullen addressed Bernard's concerns by saying that `the new tactical directive did not change the ROE in Afghanistan, but rather provided more clarification and guidelines regarding the use of force. We have refined our procedures in order to reduce civilian casualties, but at no time have the ROE been modified to place our troops at greater risk,' Mullen wrote. `Our troops still operate under a set of ROE that allows them to protect themselves against enemy actions in balance with the Afghan populace.' ''
Sergeant Bernard, a retired Marine who served this Nation, said ``the letter is `smoke and mirrors' and overlooks his consistent concern: A counterinsurgency strategy won't work as long as Afghanistan is filled with warring tribes that have no empathy for the U.S. and its way of life.''
I further want to read down in his response in the Marine Corps Times: ``I already talked to Collins' office and said, `Don't let him spin this crap.' There's no indication that Afghanistan has changed anywhere. Our mission should be very, very simple: Chase and kill the enemy.''
Madam Speaker, that's exactly what they should be doing, instead of this other type of strategy.
Bernard said he is frustrated that the senator's office, one of his home State senators and a member of the Senate Armed Service Committee, has handled his complaints as that of a single constituent--and I'm not getting into
whether they did or didn't, but just reading what he said--rather, seeing for what he is: representative of the hundreds of people-- hundreds of people--he says have contacted him about this whole rules of engagement. I want to quote, and this will be the close: `` `You can't turn this into one lone idiot in the backwoods of Maine mourning his son,' he said. `This is bigger than that.' ''
So, Madam Speaker, I intend to ask the Armed Services Committee, which is chaired by a wonderful man from Missouri, and the ranking member from California, we need to have this debate on behalf of the families as well as the Marines and the Army. What are the rules of engagement? What can they do and cannot do? When I read these articles about the number that have died just because we could not give them cover in certain situations, if that's the way we're supposed to fight a war, then that's a poor way to fight the war.
Madam Speaker, with that, I'm going to close as I always do. I know the gentleman from Texas has a tribute to pay to a former Member who I happened to serve one term with and thought the world of him. My daddy knew him and thought Charlie Wilson was a great guy. Let me get that on the Record.
My close is this: I ask God to please bless our men and women in uniform. I ask God to please bless the families of our men and women in uniform. I ask God to please bless this country and bless the President, that he will do what is right for this country. And I ask God to please bless America.