S.Amdt. 2835Senate109th Congress (2005-2007)2nd degree

S.Amdt. 2835

What it does: Rewrites page 315, line 1 through page 318, line 2
Submitted February 14, 2006

What it changes

1 change to S.Amdt. 2746

Replaces text
  1. Rewrites page 315, line 1 through page 318, line 2

    Replaces

    Removes page 315, line 1 through page 318, line 2.

    Inserted: SEC. 403. EFFECT ON OTHER LAWS AND EXISTING CLAIMS.

    Inserted: (a) Effect on Federal and State Law.--The provisions of this Act shall supersede any Federal or State law insofar as such law may relate to any asbestos claim, including any claim described under subsection (e)(2).

    Inserted: (b) Effect on Silica Claims.--

    Inserted: (1) In general.--

    Inserted: (A) Rule of construction.--Nothing in this Act shall be construed to preempt, bar, or otherwise preclude any civil action in Federal or State court seeking damages for personal injury attributable to exposure to silica as to which the plaintiff--

    Inserted: (i) pleads with particularity and establishes by a preponderance of evidence either that--

    Inserted: (I) no claim has been asserted or filed by or with respect to the exposed person in any forum for any asbestos-related condition and the exposed person (or another claiming on behalf of or through the exposed person) is not eligible for any monetary award under this Act; or

    Inserted: (II)(aa) the exposed person suffers or has suffered from a disease or condition that was caused by exposure to silica; and

    Inserted: (bb) asbestos exposure was not a substantial contributing factor to such disease or condition; and

    Inserted: (ii) satisfies the requirements of paragraph (2).

    Inserted: (B) Preemption.--Civil actions seeking damages for personal injury attributable to exposure to silica that fail to meet the requirements of subparagraph (A) shall be preempted by this Act.

    Inserted: (2) Required evidence.--In any claim to which paragraph (1) applies, the complaint (or, for claims pending on the date of enactment of this Act, an amended pleading to be filed within 60 days after such date, but not later than 60 days before trial) shall be accompanied by--

    Show 8 more inserted paragraphs

    Inserted: (A) admissible evidence, including at a minimum, a B-reader's report, and the underlying x-ray film showing that the claim may be maintained and is not preempted under paragraph (1);

    Inserted: (B) notice of any previous lawsuit or claim for benefits in which the exposed person, or another claiming on behalf of or through the injured person, asserted an injury or disability based wholly or in part on exposure to asbestos;

    Inserted: (C) if known by the plaintiff after reasonable inquiry by the plaintiff or his representative, the history of the exposed person's exposure, if any, to asbestos; and

    Inserted: (D) copies of all medical and laboratory reports pertaining to the exposed person that refer to asbestos or asbestos exposure.

    Inserted: (3) Statute of limitations.--In general, the statute of limitations for a silica claim shall be governed by applicable State law, except that in any case under this subsection, the statute of limitations shall only start to run when the plaintiff becomes impaired.

    Inserted: (4) Dual injury.--If an exposed person has both a silica disease or conditions resulting from exposure to silica and a disease or condition resulting from exposure to asbestos, any damages awarded for a claim that meets the requirements of paragraph (2)--

    Inserted: (A) shall be limited to damages attributable to the exposed person's exposure to silica; and

    Inserted: (B) shall not include damages attributable to the exposed person's exposure to asbestos.

    Original wording

    On page 315, strike line 1 and all that follows through page 318, line 2, and insert the following:

Read automatically from the Congressional Record. Check the original before relying on it.

As printed

SA 2835. Mr. KENNEDY submitted an amendment intended to be proposed to amendment SA 2746 proposed by Mr. Frist (for Mr. Specter (for himself and Mr. Leahy)) to the bill S. 852, to create a fair and efficient system to resolve claims of victims for bodily injury caused by asbestos exposure, and for other purposes; which was ordered to lie on the table; as follows:

On page 315, strike line 1 and all that follows through page 318, line 2, and insert the following:

SEC. 403. EFFECT ON OTHER LAWS AND EXISTING CLAIMS.

(a) Effect on Federal and State Law.--The provisions of this Act shall supersede any Federal or State law insofar as such law may relate to any asbestos claim, including any claim described under subsection (e)(2).

(b) Effect on Silica Claims.--

(1) In general.--

(A) Rule of construction.--Nothing in this Act shall be construed to preempt, bar, or otherwise preclude any civil action in Federal or State court seeking damages for personal injury attributable to exposure to silica as to which the plaintiff--

(i) pleads with particularity and establishes by a preponderance of evidence either that--

(I) no claim has been asserted or filed by or with respect to the exposed person in any forum for any asbestos-related condition and the exposed person (or another claiming on behalf of or through the exposed person) is not eligible for any monetary award under this Act; or

(II)(aa) the exposed person suffers or has suffered from a disease or condition that was caused by exposure to silica; and

(bb) asbestos exposure was not a substantial contributing factor to such disease or condition; and

(ii) satisfies the requirements of paragraph (2).

(B) Preemption.--Civil actions seeking damages for personal injury attributable to exposure to silica that fail to meet the requirements of subparagraph (A) shall be preempted by this Act.

(2) Required evidence.--In any claim to which paragraph (1) applies, the complaint (or, for claims pending on the date of enactment of this Act, an amended pleading to be filed within 60 days after such date, but not later than 60 days before trial) shall be accompanied by--

(A) admissible evidence, including at a minimum, a B-reader's report, and the underlying x-ray film showing that the claim may be maintained and is not preempted under paragraph (1);

(B) notice of any previous lawsuit or claim for benefits in which the exposed person, or another claiming on behalf of or through the injured person, asserted an injury or disability based wholly or in part on exposure to asbestos;

(C) if known by the plaintiff after reasonable inquiry by the plaintiff or his representative, the history of the exposed person's exposure, if any, to asbestos; and

(D) copies of all medical and laboratory reports pertaining to the exposed person that refer to asbestos or asbestos exposure.

(3) Statute of limitations.--In general, the statute of limitations for a silica claim shall be governed by applicable State law, except that in any case under this subsection, the statute of limitations shall only start to run when the plaintiff becomes impaired.

(4) Dual injury.--If an exposed person has both a silica disease or conditions resulting from exposure to silica and a disease or condition resulting from exposure to asbestos, any damages awarded for a claim that meets the requirements of paragraph (2)--

(A) shall be limited to damages attributable to the exposed person's exposure to silica; and

(B) shall not include damages attributable to the exposed person's exposure to asbestos.

Legislative Activity

Stay on top of the latest movement without scrolling through every action

Floor Latest Action

Senate amendment submitted

February 14, 2006