Mr. Chairman, I move to strike the last word. Mr. Chairman, I rise today in strong opposition to the amendment offered by Mr. Westmoreland to eliminate funding for the Native Hawaiian Housing Block…
Mr. Chairman, I move to strike the last word.
Mr. Chairman, I rise today in strong opposition to the amendment offered by Mr. Westmoreland to eliminate funding for the Native Hawaiian Housing Block Grant program.
The Native Hawaiian Housing Block Grant is authorized under title VIII of the Native American Housing Assistance and Self-Determination Act (NAHASDA). The block grant is used to carry out affordable housing activities for Native Hawaiian families who are eligible to reside on Hawaiian
homelands which were established in trust by the United States in 1921 under the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act (HHCA).
Due to a variety of factors, including long-term leases for purposes outside of the HHCA and the lack of funding for infrastructure, only 8,000 individuals currently hold leases, and approximately 19,000 remain on a waiting list, and many of our elderly, our kapuna, have died waiting for the dream of home ownership.
I submit for printing in the Record an article from the Honolulu Star Bulletin that introduces these families to us.
[From the Honolulu Star-Bulletin, July 9, 2006.]
Homestead awards end long wait for lucky few--One Hawaiian homestead is
awarded to a woman 57 years after her father applied.
(By Alexandre Da Silva with Leila Fujimori)
The line for a homestead was so long for Aloysius Lincoln
that he never saw the end of it.
But yesterday, 57 years after the former Honolulu Gas Co.
employee applied for a lease, his daughter claimed the lease
awarded for the second phase of a Department of Hawaiian Home
Lands project in Kapolei.
``Unfortunately, he died two years ago. He was 87,'' said
Frances Segundo, 60, who was a baby when her father signed up
for the program. ``However, his legacy goes on, because this
award is for our ohana, our family.''
About 2,000 people showed up yesterday morning at the Neal
S. Blaisdell Center Exhibition Hall, where the Department of
Hawaiian Home Lands awarded 250 lots in Phase 2 and Phase 3
of in their Kaupe'a project in Kapolei.
The 52-acre subdivision has 326 lots, 76 of which were
awarded in November 2005.
Segundo, a clerk at Maui Community College, said her
cousin, Naira Martin, would live in the four-bedroom, three-
bathroom house with her daughter, but there would always be
room for another relative.
``I'm free from the rent, which is going to be over with,''
said Martin, 56. The $2,000 she pays each month for rent will
now go toward her mortgage. ``When the whole family comes
from the mainland, Louisiana, they will stay with me. It's a
very good feeling.''
Gov. Linda Lingle, who was present for yesterday's
selection meeting, said the latest awards would help the
state's shortage of affordable rentals as new homeowners are
able to free up rental homes and apartments.
``Those units now become available for the general
public,'' Lingle said. ``It is better for the entire
community.''
Yesterday's crowd was a fraction of the nearly 20,000
native Hawaiians currently on the homestead waiting list,
about half of which are on Oahu, said Lloyd Yonenaka, a
spokesman for the Hawaiian Home Lands Department.
Even though more than 1,200 leases have been given out
since 2003, the department's waiting list keeps growing, at a
pace of about 100 people a month, Yonenaka said.
To qualify, applicants must have at least 50 percent
Hawaiian blood and be pre-approved to afford one of the five
Kaupe'a models, which range between $238,600 and $296,100 in
lots averaging 5,000 square feet. The lease rent for the land
under their homes is $1 per year.
The first phase of the Kaupe'a project is expected to be
completed by the end of the year, while Phase 2 and Phase 3
should be done in the first and second quarters of 2007,
according to the department.
As she signed documents for her new lease yesterday, Vivian
Perreira, 71, said she would vacate her Maili home in
Waianae--where she lives with husband, Alfred, her son and
his two children--sometime next year. Perreira said her
youngest son, 47-year-old Prince, a refuse truck driver for
Rolloffs Hawaii Inc., had to co-sign her application because
her Social Security earnings weren't enough for a loan.
After waiting 48 years for her name to be called, Perreira,
now in a wheelchair, will lease a four-bedroom home on a
corner lot in Kapolei.
``I signed up when I was 23,'' she said. ``I almost gave
up, but I left my name on for so long.''
The federal government set up the Hawaiian Homes Commission
Act in 1921, eventually reserving 200,000 acres statewide to
benefit native Hawaiians. But development of land to provide
homes has been slow, and many families have been on the
waiting list for decades.
Last month the state Supreme Court ruled that 2,700 native
Hawaiians can seek monetary damages in a lawsuit against the
state for its alleged mismanagement of the Hawaiian Home
Lands program.
Not everyone who came yesterday had a happy story to share.
Homes went to 250 families, but 750 people qualified for
lots, which are awarded on the basis of seniority. People who
have qualified and waited the longest are the next in line
for a home.
Lee Kogler, 54, who has been researching her genealogy for
more than 20 years, had to leave without a lease after
arriving at 7 a.m. with her husband, daughter, grandson and
two sons.
Kogler turned in her paperwork in 1991. But after marrying
and moving to New York, Kogler's application was returned,
with the department saying she needed to show the Hawaiian
lineage on her father's side. Finally, in 1994, Kogler combed
through the bound volumes of records at the state Archives,
where she found a Census Bureau report listing her
grandmother, Hannah Kaulia, at age 19, living in the house of
her father, Samuel, a master carpenter.
Kogler, who is number 7,954 on the wait list for Oahu, said
she would never quit trying for a lease.
``It's not a sad day,'' Kogler said, citing plans by the
department to award another 300 lots in Kapolei in October.
``I'm still with hope. I've waited a long time for this, and
I'm not going to give up.''
Aloysius Lincoln first applied for Hawaiian Home Lands in 1949. In 2006, a wait of 57 years, his daughter, Frances Segundo, claimed the lease awarded for the second phase of a Department of Hawaiian Home Lands project on the Island of Oahu. Frances claimed the lease because her father had, unfortunately, passed away 2 years before. Frances herself, now 60 years old, was a baby when her father first signed up for the program. Frances stated that ``[her father's] legacy goes on because this award is for our ohana, our family.''
That is something I would like this body to remember: That this is not just money we are talking about today. We are talking about the opportunity for families to live the American dream of home ownership, and Native Hawaiian families are among those with the greatest need. A study conducted in 1996 by the Urban Institute, the National Commission on the American Indian, Alaska Native, and Native Hawaiian Housing, and the State Department of Hawaiian Home Lands, found that nearly half of Hawaiian households and 67 percent of those on waiting lists for Hawaiian Homes Lands experienced housing problems related to affordability, overcrowding, or structural inadequacy. That compares with 44 percent of American Indians and Alaska Natives living on tribal lands, and 27 percent of all U.S. households.
In 1992, 49 percent of Hawaiian Home Lands applicants lived in overcrowded conditions compared with 37 percent of all Hawaiian households, and 21 percent of non-Hawaiian households. Twenty-eight percent of Hawaiian households put more than 30 percent of income toward housing compared with 22 percent for non-Hawaiians. The rate of homelessness among Hawaiians at 12.2 households per 1,000 is double that of non-Hawaiians.
In 1982, the U.S. Secretary of the Interior and the Governor of the State of Hawaii established a Federal-State task force to renew HHCA and the programs carried under that act. The Federal-State task force issued a report in 1983 with specific recommendations, including one that the State and Federal Government should each make contributions of $29 million per year to accelerate the program.
For the first time in 2000, Federal funding was made available when housing assistance for Native Hawaiians was added to NAHASDA through the Native Hawaiian Block Grant. This amendment follows what I sense is a developing pattern of challenges to programs benefiting Native American, Alaska Native, and Native Hawaiian people.
The earlier failed challenge to the previously uncontroversial Native Hawaiian Housing Act earlier this year was the first apparent salvo against Native American programs. The attempt to strike funds in the Labor and Education appropriations bill for the Alaska Native, Native Hawaiian-Serving Institutions, and the Higher Education Act raises the concerns that all programs benefiting Native Americans will be subjected to attack by certain groups.
The same arguments of constitutionality of these programs benefiting Native Americans have been raised and rejected by this body time and again. This is not race-based discrimination. The relationship between the United States and Native Americans is based on a political relationship, as Supreme Court decisions have consistently held.
Like other indigenous peoples, such as Native Americans and Alaska Natives, Native Hawaiians have a special trust relationship with the United States. It has been well settled that Congress has clear plenary power to fulfill its obligations to indigenous people who once had sovereign governing entities before the establishment of the United States, and whose lands are currently within the borders of the United States. Like Native
Americans and Alaska Natives, Native Hawaiians suffered the loss of their sovereignty and lands to the United States.
I could go on, Mr. Chairman, but for these and many other reasons, I strongly urge my colleagues to vote against this amendment.