Executive Session
Mr. President, I ask unanimous consent that the order for the quorum call be rescinded. Mr. President, as the senior Senator from Arkansas, I am proud to come to the floor and join my colleague Senator Mark Pryor today to introduce Leon…
Mr. President, I ask unanimous consent that the order for the quorum call be rescinded.
Mr. President, as the senior Senator from Arkansas, I am proud to come to the floor and join my colleague Senator Mark Pryor today to introduce Leon Holmes to my colleagues here in the Senate and express my support for his nomination.
Mr. Holmes is a native of Hazen, AR, in Prairie County, which is not too far from my hometown of Helena. He is the fourth of seven children and the first in his family to go to college. He has been married to his wife Susan Holmes for 32 years, and he is the proud father of five children and has seven grandchildren.
Most of us having been home not only working during the Fourth of July recess but hopefully spending some time with our families understand how important our families and our children and future generations are to all of us. I know Mr. Holmes has certainly expressed that to me.
After high school, Leon graduated with special distinction from Arkansas State University in 1973. He continued his education by earning a law degree from the University of Arkansas where he graduated first in his class.
Mr. Holmes later received a master's degree in political philosophy from Northern Illinois University and a doctorate in political science from Duke University where he was inducted into Phi Beta Kappa.
Leon's professional career is equally impressive. In addition to being named a partner in the law firm of Quattlebaum, Grooms, Tull, and Burrow in Little Rock, Mr. Holmes has held a variety of positions, including law clerk for Justice Frank Holt on the Arkansas Supreme Court, assistant professor at Augustana College in Rock Island, IL, and adjunct faculty member of the University of Arkansas at Little Rock School of Law.
As an attorney in private practice, Leon has had a wide-ranging legal practice, representing large corporations, small businesses, and individual litigants, and although I am not a part of the legal community in my home State of Arkansas as a lawyer like my colleague Senator Pryor is, I have heard from a number of practicing lawyers, judges, and others throughout our State who have worked with Leon and have the utmost confidence in his ability to administer the rule of law.
But Leon has not spent his whole life in the library or at a law firm. As you well know, Mr. President, that certainly is something that is important to me. You may be interested to know that in his youth, Leon actually chopped and picked cotton over in our part of the State in eastern Arkansas. He worked as a farm laborer in the fields of Prairie County and served as a carpenter's helper. While pursuing his education, he worked as a door-to-door salesman and as a newspaper carrier to help make ends meet.
In short, during his academic and professional career, Leon has distinguished himself as a scholar and an accomplished lawyer. In the process, he has earned the trust, admiration, and respect of his friends and colleagues with whom he has lived and worked.
As a farmer's daughter from eastern Arkansas, I believe the fact that Mr. Holmes knows the value of an honest day's work both as a lawyer and a laborer is a good indication that he has the life experience required to administer the law in a very fair and impartial manner, regardless of who the litigants are before him.
If that were the only part of the record before us, the debate we are having today would be a very short one. As some of my colleagues have said or will say during the consideration of this nomination, Leon is also a devoutly religious man who has written articles and made statements that are a reflection of his faith, but they are also somewhat controversial. We all know that for many of us our faith is very important. It is important for us to have an opportunity to express our faith, to talk about it, to speak about it, to live it in a way that is very important to us and reflective of our own ministry.
There is no doubt I have been troubled by some of the statements attributed to Mr. Holmes, particularly one regarding the role of a woman in a marital relationship. As a mother and a wife, I can assure you, I consider myself equal in every way to my husband. Our marriage is based on mutual love and respect, which sustains our union as a man and a wife.
I think it is so important in this day and age as we talk about marriage and its importance to our family, to our children, to the stability of the fabric of this great country, that we understand marriage does not just happen; it has to be those two individuals who come together, a man and a woman, working equally as hard at making sure that union is strong and that it is working.
However, I fully respect the right of Mr. Holmes to practice and express his religious beliefs freely, even those with which I may not agree, just as I expect others to respect my right to do the same.
Mr. Holmes also made a comment 20-plus years ago about how women who were raped do not get pregnant, which I think most would agree was inappropriate and offensive. But Mr. Holmes has apologized for that comment. He has acknowledged it was wrong and said he regrets saying it. We have all said things we should not and wished we had not said in our lives and I, for one, accept his apology. I do believe it is very critical we understand the complications, the emotions, and everything else that are wrapped up in the circumstances when women find themselves in those circumstances of rape or incest or being abused. Again, I do accept Mr. Holmes' apology.
Mr. President, I ask unanimous consent that a letter from Leon Holmes to me apologizing for this remark and responding to the criticism of other statements be printed in the Record.
In making my decision to support Mr. Holmes' nomination, I have considered many factors. There is no question he has the necessary legal skills and intellect to perform the duties of the position. More importantly, I have been impressed with the overwhelming support Leon has received from his friends, coworkers, and colleagues in Arkansas' legal community who have firsthand knowledge of his temperament, his character, and abilities as a lawyer. I have received countless letters, e-mails, and phone calls from all over the State expressing strong support for Leon's nomination. Many of these contacts are from people I know personally and several, if not most, are from very active, self-described, very strong Democrats.
Those from Arkansas who have contacted me and the Judiciary Committee in support of this nomination include a past president of the American Bar Association, a former president of the Arkansas Trial Lawyers Association, a founder of the Arkansas affiliate of the ACLU, sitting Federal judges who are familiar with Leon's work, female attorneys who have argued cases with and against Leon, and many others.
One letter from a self-described liberal Democrat who is also decidedly pro-choice summed up how Mr. Holmes is viewed in Arkansas' legal community when he wrote that after litigating ``with and against Leon for a number of years'' he had so much faith and trust in him that he would ``shoot dice with him over the telephone.'' Now that might not sound too common to folks up here, but in Arkansas it is a pretty good saying, and it certainly indicates a great deal of trust on that gentleman's part of the gentleman with whom he was dealing, and that was Mr. Leon Holmes.
In conclusion, I do not determine my support or opposition to a nominee based solely on whether we share the same philosophy, ideology, or beliefs. Fundamentally, I am interested in knowing a judicial nominee can fulfill his or her responsibility under the Constitution to apply the law fairly without political favor or personal bias.
I am satisfied Mr. Leon Holmes has met that standard based on the strong support he has received from those who know him the best and his assurances to me when we met personally. He assured me personally he is willing and able to set aside his personal beliefs to fulfill his duties as a Federal district court judge.
Senator Pryor and I are here to support Leon Holmes. He has done a good job in Arkansas.
He is a good man, a good friend, and a well-trusted lawyer among his colleagues. We encourage our colleagues in the Senate to look at the evidence we have presented and certainly judge this man on the basis of all of these incredible character witnesses, as well as his own testimony, in being sure that we can all have the confidence that Mr. Holmes will, without a doubt, implement the law, the rule of law, according to the rule of law, and not based on his own personal views.
I thank my colleagues for their attention, and I yield the floor.