Mr. President, I ask unanimous consent that at 4:30 this afternoon the Senate proceed to vote in relation to the amendments listed in this agreement and in the order listed; that no amendment be in order to any of the amendments covered…
Mr. President, I ask unanimous consent that at 4:30 this afternoon the Senate proceed to vote in relation to the amendments listed in this agreement and in the order listed; that no amendment be in order to any of the amendments covered under the agreement prior to a vote in relation thereto; that prior to each vote, there be 2 minutes of debate equally divided and controlled in the usual form; that after the first vote in the sequence, the succeeding votes be limited to 10 minutes each: McCain amendment No. 364, and that the amendment be modified with the change at the desk; Dorgan amendment No. 200; Feingold-McCain amendment No. 140; Dodd amendment No. 354; DeMint amendment No. 189; Harkin amendment No. 338; Dodd amendment No. 145; McCaskill amendment No. 125; Ensign amendment No. 353; McCaskill amendment No. 236, as modified, and that a further modification be in order if cleared by the managers; Thune amendment No. 197; Boxer amendment No. 363, as amended; and Barrasso amendment No. 326.
Mr. President, there will be ample opportunity to offer amendments.
Yes.
Mr. President, I ask unanimous consent that Dodd amendment No. 145 be taken out of this tranche. We will arrange another time, with the assistance of the Republicans, to determine when to vote on this. What we are trying to do, Senator Conrad wants to have another amendment go before this one, and Senator Dodd has consented to do that.
That is right.
I thank the Chair.
Amendment No. 338--Withdrawn
Mr. President, the vote has been reported?
Mr. President, for all Members, everyone should be advised we are going to be working late tonight. We have a lot of work to do. We are going to work to get a solution. We are going to work within the broad outline that President Obama has given us, a program that has the wide support of the American people.
If necessary, we are going to work through the night. I repeat, we are going to work until we get it done. There are a number of Senators working in good faith to try to come up with a proposal that will pick up a number of Republican votes. There are a number of Republicans working in that group--I do not know how many but as many as eight Republican Senators--trying to come up with a proposal they believe would improve this legislation.
As I have indicated to each of those Senators individually, we would be happy to take a look at this. If it is in keeping with what I believe everyone is trying to do; that is, to improve this legislation, of course we will take a look at it, and we will take a good positive look at it.
This legislation is very important. The reason we need to work through the night is, I cannot imagine what would happen to the financial markets tomorrow if it was reported that this bill would go down. This bill is not only important to our great country, it is important to the world. We are the largest economic machine in the world by far.
People a lot of times refer to Japan and the trouble they had in the 1990s. But, remember, their economy, even though theirs is the second largest economy in the world, it is a very small economy relatively speaking compared to ours. So around the world, everyone is looking at what we are going to do tonight.
I want to make sure everyone understands that everyone is working in good faith. This is a very large piece of legislation. I understand why people would want to change it, and certainly we are in the process of trying to do that with these multitude of amendments that have been offered.
We will finish this. We have about four votes left in this tranche. Then we will move on to others. On the Democratic side, we have more amendments lined up. I am sure the Republicans have more lined up on their side. But I would hope everyone would work in good faith to move forward on this legislation.
If at the end of the day people cannot vote for it, that is a decision people will have to make. But I want everyone
within the sound of my voice to understand that what we do here is extremely important not only to the people in Las Vegas, Reno, and Nevada but all over this country and the financial capitals of the world.
The small towns all around the world are looking to see what we do. It is not a pleasant picture to think what would happen if this legislation, which was put together--I have used the term before--in good faith by President Obama and his people, is, in effect, turned down.
Now, we have never said you have to rubberstamp what we have done. That is why we started on Monday a process of amending this legislation. A lot of amendments have been offered. A lot of them have not been accepted or approved, but a number of them have. A couple of them that were approved I really did not like very much. But this is what the legislative process is about. Legislation is the art of compromise, consensus building. That is where we are. So it is 6:15 tonight. I would hope in the next 12 hours we can have a piece of legislation that we can feel good about after having worked on it for these many hours that we have.
I failed to say one thing. I extend my apologies to my friend. One of the things I wanted to say is, Senator McConnell, the Republican leader, has been very open with me. We have had a number of meetings during today. He has been very understanding of some of the problems I have. I am understanding of some of the problems he has.
I want the Record to reflect he has been very cooperative. I appreciate that very much.
Mr. President, I am probably different than most every Senator. I wish we could outlaw polls. I think they are one of the things that hurt the body politic. I don't believe in them. I don't watch what they say. I don't care about them. But I can read them. We were all present at a meeting yesterday where in-depth polling has been done on this. The polling for President Obama's package, as of yesterday, was approved by nearly 70 percent of the American people. I don't know what the Gallup poll is, but it should underscore what I said about polls. Everybody forget about the polls. Forget about them. Do what we think is good for the American people based on what we are hearing from constituents, constituents rich and poor, big businesses and small businesses. If we listen to them, we have to come forward with a robust package in keeping with the needs of the country.
I appreciate the comments of my friend, the Republican leader. We are all working to do the best we can. We have some disagreement as to what the right thing to do is. I hope we will not be determining what we do based on a poll.
I have stated clearly and unequivocally that I believe those eight Republicans who are--I think that is the number; I haven't been in on the meetings--working very hard to try to come up with an alternate proposal, I appreciate that. Does that mean the other 33 Republican Senators aren't working in good faith? Of course they are. But I very much appreciate those Republicans who are openly trying to come up with something different. All of us are trying to do the right thing for the American people. There isn't a single Senator who has come to this floor who hasn't said that this economy is in deep trouble and we have to do something to fix it. My comment was, I hope we can do that. That is the reason I have said we have to work through the night. Because if we don't and the Friday financial markets look at us not having been able to accomplish anything, it is a bad day not only for America but the rest of the world.
Amendment No. 236, As Further Modified
Mr. President, I rise to discuss an amendment that I have filed to address some important renewable energy issues that should be resolved before the Congress sends the final economic recovery plan to the President.
I do not plan to force it to a vote because I have great confidence that we will be able to work out most, if not all, of these issues satisfactorily in conference and with the new administration. That is provided we can get enough votes to move this critical bill through the Senate.
As my colleagues know, the recession has hit every sector of the economy hard. The growing renewable energy industry is no exception. One recent headline was ``Dark Days for Green Energy.''
Solar, wind and even geothermal businesses are caught in the credit crunch. Installations have slowed, despite the extensions of important production and investment tax credits that we included in the Troubled Asset Relief Program and the promise of the new renewable and energy efficiency incentives and loan guarantee programs that we have included in the economic recovery legislation the Senate is debating now.
The number of investors for new renewable projects, like other industries, has dwindled due to the disruption in tax equity markets. So, to keep making progress toward a clean energy revolution, making our Nation and my home State of Nevada more energy independent and creating thousands of new jobs and sustainable economic growth, we need a temporary substitute for those tax credits and incentives.
My amendment is similar to the temporary DOE grant program included in the House-passed bill, which works in lieu of the investment tax credit. However, I have modified it to be certain that it also works for utility-scale solar and geothermal projects which take slightly longer than wind or other renewable energy production facilities to commence operation.
Clearly, this grant program will not and should not remove the strong preference of most project sponsors to use the traditional tax equity markets once those markets are reestablished and functioning. The grant option is less valuable to these investors than the investment or production tax credit because it does not fully replace other tax benefits such as accelerated depreciation. But the grant program is a necessity in today's troubled market
that will get renewable project developers through these difficult times, creating thousands of jobs in the course of months instead of years.
The amendment does a number of other things, including pushing and funding the Departments of Energy, Interior and other agencies to work together more constructively and more quickly to process renewable energy projects and related transmission permits on public lands. It also raises the cap to $2.5 billion on third-party financing for transmission capacity developments that the Western Area Power Administration and the Southwestern Power Administration are allowed to accept.
Lastly, the amendment includes a nod toward the problems faced by solar and other renewable technologies that might not easily fall into the two categories of guaranteed loan eligibility in the substitute, commercial vs. non-commercial. My amendment would add a new category of ``new or significantly improved'' technologies that would be eligible for the new loan guarantee program created in the underlying bill. This definition was part of the final rule for the title XVII loan guarantee program published in October 2007.
Nevadans and all Americans are eager to get back to work and clean energy investments are one of the best ways to ensure they can get back to work and prosper.
Nevadans pay billions of dollars every year in energy bills. Much of that money goes to other States or other countries in fuel costs and enriches them, but does not add equivalent and long-lasting value for Nevada or provide much help to diversify our economy or prepare for a safer and more affordable future.
Fortunately, this economic recovery plan, with the help of the new administration, is going to start the transformation of our national energy policy that Nevada needs to become a net exporter of clean renewable energy.
This bill will stimulate the economy in the short-term, but its energy spending will have long-term benefits for Nevada and the Nation.
The entire list of potential benefits to Nevada are too numerous to list, but at my and the President's strong urging, the economic recovery bill will, for example: accelerate renewable energy project and transmission line development; stimulate the growth of businesses making energy efficient and renewable energy products and services; improve energy efficiency of schools, hospitals, public buildings and low-income housing; maintain, repair and improve critical water supply and quality projects in urban and rural areas; promote conversion of vehicle fleets to clean and efficient alternative fuels to reduce oil consumption; and, enhance energy security at military installations through renewable energy and energy efficiency investments.
Some of the specific items currently in the bill and their benefits for Nevada:
A 3 year extension of the renewable energy production tax credit. The long-term extension of this tax credit are critical to ensure investment in Nevada's geothermal and wind energy potential. $3.25 billion in new borrowing authority for the Western Area Power Administration to finance and facilitate development of renewable energy transmission capacity. The new borrowing authority should facilitate access to Nevada's vast solar and geothermal resources. $22.1 million through the Weatherization Assistance Program, with changes to the income level percentage formula for determining the eligibility, an increase in the assistance level per dwelling unit, and an increase in the funding ceiling for worker training. $5.4 million through the State Energy Program for energy efficiency, conservation and renewable energy projects. A new Advanced Energy Investment Credit for facilities that manufacture advanced energy property like solar cells or mirrors, wind turbines, technology that can access geothermal deposits, or energy storage systems for electric and hybrid-electric vehicles. $1.6 billion in Clean Renewable Energy Bonds that Nevada's cities, counties, and electric cooperatives will be able to compete for to finance renewable energy and energy efficiency projects. A 2 year extension and expansion of the 10 percent energy efficiency tax credit for existing homes to 30 percent. Approximately $20 million for energy efficiency and conservation block grants for Nevada's communities. Hundreds of millions of dollars that will make military installations more energy efficient and more energy secure through greater use of renewable power and alternative fuel vehicles. $2 billion that Nevada's public housing agencies will be able to compete for so that they can invest in energy conservation. $1.6 billion that Nevada's hospitals and schools will be able to compete for so that they can invest in energy efficiency
I should note that nothing is final until the Senate has had a chance to pass and conference this bill with the House and President Obama has signed it. Many Senators have filed or are considering amendments to cut some of these important energy programs. So we will have to see what happens.
But I am committed to making sure that the renewable energy business in Nevada and elsewhere continues to grow through this legislative package, the next energy bill and beyond. The economic, energy, environmental and national security benefits are just too important to my State, to the Nation and the world.
Mr. President, although the housing crisis has devastated cities and towns across America, nowhere has been hit harder than Nevada.
Nearly 1 in 20 households has been affected by foreclosure, and that number goes up every single day.
Every time a home is lost, a family loses not just a place to live but a sense of security, financial stability and the promise of a brighter future.
Last evening, the Senate passed an amendment to the American recovery and reinvestment plan that doubles the tax credit for home buyers to $15,000. This legislation will also expand the credit to all purchasers, not just first-time buyers.
In Nevada, this incentive will help encourage those who continue to sit on the fence, hoping for further price declines, to jump into the market and buy a home. Despite the current uncertainty, many experts agree that for the long term, now is an excellent time to become a homeowner.
Nevadans know that this amendment will not solve our housing crisis, but it will help. If Democrats and Republicans keep working together with President Obama, putting partisanship aside to find commonsense solutions, we can stabilize our housing market and begin the long road to economic recovery.
I suggest the absence of a quorum.
Mr. President, I ask unanimous consent that the order for the quorum call be rescinded.
Mr. President, we have a lot of amendments still pending. I have made a decision in conjunction and in cooperation with the Republican leader
that we are going to stop legislating tonight and come back tomorrow, come in at 10 o'clock. We will go immediately to the bill. There are a number of amendments pending. Other Senators want to offer amendments.
The main reason I look forward to tomorrow is there are a number of Republican Senators working with Democratic Senators trying to come up with an alternative proposal. Now, I hope something works out. I know everyone is trying in good faith to move this ball down the court. But I think we need the night and some time tomorrow to see if we can do that. There is paper floating back and forth that is becoming filled with numbers, and we all need to take a look at this.
The work done by the negotiators, as I indicated earlier--about eight Republicans, about the same number of Democrats, trying to work toward making this a better piece of legislation--is ongoing. If, in fact, we find tomorrow that we are spinning our wheels, cannot get something done, then we will file cloture and have a Sunday cloture vote.
Now, Mr. President, I am optimistic we can get something done, and I hope that, in fact, is the case. Everyone is going to have to give a little and understand that this is a process where we have to move this ball down the court. The Republican leader has indicated to me that if we get this out of here, we should go to conference. I agree with him. That takes a little bit of time, and I would hope we could complete this legislation tomorrow. I have hopes, and I am cautiously optimistic we can do that.
So I wish I had all the answers, but the answers are not here tonight. I think the answers have been coming forth more rapidly in the last few days. I think staying here later tonight would not benefit us. We have a number of amendments we could dispose of, but I think we are waiting for the big amendment that has been worked on now for all this week.
I will be happy to.
Absolutely.
Yes. We will come in at 10 o'clock. The managers of the bill should be here. We will go directly to the legislation. There will be votes. We could have votes early in the morning because there are amendments right now pending that the manager on this side could move to table, setting up a string of votes. But the answer to the Republican leader is, yes, we will process amendments.
I suggest the absence of a quorum.