Mr. Speaker, I thank the gentleman for yielding me this time. Mr. Speaker, I rise today in strong support of H.R. 5, because there is absolutely a medical liability crisis in Florida which will, among other things, result in patients in…
Mr. Speaker, I thank the gentleman for yielding me this time.
Mr. Speaker, I rise today in strong support of H.R. 5, because there is absolutely a medical liability crisis in Florida which will, among other things, result in patients in Orlando with severe head injuries not having access to a doctor. Let me give one example of the crisis.
The Orlando Regional Medical Center is a large hospital located in the heart of my district in Orlando, Florida. It is home to the only level-1 trauma center in the central Florida area. It specializes in treating patients with severe head injuries. The trauma center was praised last month by the State of Florida as delivering patient care that is ``above and beyond'' that of other level-1 trauma centers. I personally toured this trauma center, and I can tell my colleagues it is a source of pride for many central Floridians.
Last week, Orlando Regional Medical Center announced that they were closing in April 2003 because the neurosurgeons in the Orlando area can no longer afford skyrocketing medical liability insurance premiums.
Now, how bad is the situation? Dr. Jonathan Greenberg, the chairman of the Department of Neurosurgery at ORMC, personally told me that the malpractice insurance premiums have risen five-fold over the past 2 years from $55,000 a year to $256,000 a year.
We do not have to guess what the consequences are when this sort of facility is closed down. Just last week, Mrs. Leanne Dyess testified before our Committee on the Judiciary. Her husband suffered one of these severe head injuries in a car accident. There were no longer any neurosurgeons in the area because they could not afford the liability insurance. As a result, it took 6 hours to airlift Mr. Dyess to a different location. It was too late. Mr. Dyess is now permanently brain damaged. He is unable to talk, unable to work, unable to provide for his family.
We must bring common sense back to the health care system so that patients with severe head injuries have access to trauma centers. We should care about each other more and sue each other less.
I ask my colleagues to vote ``yes'' on H.R. 5 and the rule. I will also include in the Record an article dated March 11, 2003 from Dr. Greenberg and published in the Orlando Sentinel.
[From the Orlando Sentinel, Mar. 11, 2003]
Neurosurgeon: Save Trauma Center
(By Jonathan Greenberg, M.D.)
A human tragedy of immense proportions is unfolding in
Central Florida, and my neurosurgical colleagues and I have
been unable to prevent it.
Less than two weeks after a state trauma-site review lauded
Orlando Regional Medical Center's Level I trauma center for
its high level of patient care and dedication ``above and
beyond'' that at other Level I centers, the ORMC
administration was compelled to inform the state that it will
go off-line as an adult Level I trauma center as of April 1
because of the lack of neurosurgical coverage.
Seven neurosurgeons resigned from the ORMC medical staff,
citing the physical stress of on-call requirements, medical
malpractice-insurance premiums, increased liability exposure
in treating trauma patients and the adverse impact that on-
call coverage has had on their private practices.
I cannot fault my neurosurgical colleagues for having taken
this action. They have complained that they were being
charged significantly increased malpractice-insurance
premiums--or were going to be denied malpractice insurance
altogether--for the privilege of getting up in the middle of
the night to take care of critically ill head and spine-
injured patients.
Three neurosurgeons have closed their practices and left
the community. Trying to replace them has been almost
impossible. What sane physician would move to a state known
to be in the throes of a ``medical malpractice-insurance
crisis,'' where insurance is either unobtainable or
exorbitantly priced, and where there is a constant threat of
frivolous but nonetheless disruptive lawsuits?
ORMC has lobbied vigorously for relief; we have
demonstrated to increase public awareness and spoken with
state representatives.
For those who denied that there was a ``physician drain''
or a problem with the tort system, who asserted that this was
only an insurance-industry, stock-market-cyclical financial
problem, who ignored the looming crisis, the end results of
denial, deception, apathy and procrastination are clear.
As of April 1, Central Florida will have lost one of its
most precious assets, the ORMC Level I trauma center. There
will not be enough neurosurgeons left to fully man the on-
call schedule.
We know that in the past many patients survived their
injuries because they were brought to ORMC; they would not
have survived elsewhere. After April 1, similarly injured
patients may not survive. I am profoundly saddened by this
prospect.
It will take more than an act of God to avert this
catastrophe. It will take responsible action by the governor,
the state Legislature, and county and regional leaders. Band-
Aid solutions will not save a health-care system that is
exsanguinating. ORMC has the only Level I trauma center in
the state without sovereign immunity. Relief from predatory
lawsuits and unaffordable insurance premiums and adequate
compensation for extraordinary medical care will be
necessary.