I want to commend the chairman for his work on this and in so many vital areas of the issue of health care on our committee, and I want to thank him for the time and the opportunity to bring this…
I want to commend the chairman for his work on this and in so many vital areas of the issue of health care on our committee, and I want to thank him for the time and the opportunity to bring this bill forward.
Mr. Speaker, the Republicans' goal in health care is to make certain that we have the highest quality health care in the world. That's our desire. We simply want it to be patient-centered health care, not government-centered health care. We believe that patients and families and doctors ought to be making medical decisions, not Washington, D.C. So this bill, H.R. 2009, grows out of the IRS's activities that have come to light in this country over the past number of months. As the chairman mentioned, we've been doing a lot of oversight hearings in our committee.
The American people have drawn a conclusion about the IRS at this point, and that conclusion is that it cannot be trusted now. The chairman mentioned that the IRS has targeted groups that have come to the IRS asking for a tax-exempt status. It has targeted groups for their political ideology. The IRS has leaked donor information to those groups, and many of us believe--and I think it will come out--that the IRS has, in fact, targeted donors to those groups for audits to those individual Americans.
Mr. Speaker, this is chilling activity from the Internal Revenue Service, so the American people have lost their faith and trust in the Internal Revenue Service. That's why this bill is so important.
This is a very simple piece of legislation--two pages, in fact. All it says, simply, is what the American people believe, and that is that the IRS should not be charged and have the authority to either implement or enforce the Affordable Care Act. I want to commend over 140 Members from this House of Representatives for being cosponsors, and we have hundreds of citizen cosponsors from across the country.
Some say that this isn't necessary, that it is not going to accomplish anything, that there is no reason the IRS would want that information anyway. The fact of the matter is that that's exactly what they said about what they did for the tax-exempt groups. They said, Well, it wasn't necessary for them to get that information about political ideology or beliefs or prayers that prayer groups were offering. That wasn't necessary either.
So, if that were not necessary, Mr. Speaker, how can the American people have faith and confidence that the IRS won't do something that also is unnecessary, and that is to engage in implementing themselves into that trusted relationship between patients and physicians?
Then another piece of evidence, Mr. Speaker, I would suggest is the individual who's running the IRS division that is charged with the enforcement of the Affordable Care Act. Mr. Speaker, that individual is Sarah Hall Ingram. You don't have to look too far back in her biography to recognize that she was the individual who was, in fact, in charge of the tax exempt group in the IRS at the time when the challenges to the IRS had been focused.
Mr. Speaker, the overwhelming percent of the American people understand and appreciate that the IRS should not be involved in the health care of this Nation. We believe patients and families and doctors ought to be making medical decisions, not Washington, D.C., and certainly not the Internal Revenue Service.
I reserve the balance of my time
Mr. Speaker, I insert into the Record a letter from The Seniors Coalition in support of H.R. 2009.
The Seniors Coalition,
Washington, DC, July 30, 2013.
Hon. Dr. Tom Price,
Cannon House Office Building,
Washington, DC.
Dear Congressman Price: I am writing to you today on behalf
of the over four million members and supporters of The
Seniors Coalition in support of your bill H.R. 2009, ``The
Keep the IRS Off Your Health Care Act.'' The Seniors
Coalition was originally founded as a public advocacy group
fighting to repeal the Medicare Catastrophic Coverage Act.
Since 1990, TSC has grown rapidly and expanded its advocacy
to include any issue that concerns America's senior citizens.
Today the Coalition is one of the largest grassroots advocacy
organizations in Washington, D.C. in terms of number of
supporters nationwide. TSC currently has over four million
supporters representing every state in the union.
The Obama Administration, including the IRS, has betrayed
the trust of the American people. Allowing the IRS to enforce
ObamaCare is opening up the door to more abuse, more
targeting and more harassment of American citizens. The vast
majority of the American people do not support ObamaCare, and
President Obama is ignoring the will of the people.
That is why The Seniors Coalition is writing today to fully
support H.R. 2009. Clearly, the IRS has proven itself either
unwilling or unable to prudently and impartially enforce the
law, and we certainly cannot trust them with our health care.
Thank you for all your hard work Dr. Price, and please
don't hesitate to contact me directly if there is anything
that The Seniors Coalition and its over four million members
and supporters in all 50 states can do to assist you in your
effort to de-fund/repeal ObamaCare.
Sincerely,
Sean Ferritor,
Executive Director.
I'm now pleased to yield 1\1/2\ minutes to the gentleman from Texas (Mr. Carter).
Mr. Speaker, I now insert into the Record a letter from the group Let Freedom Ring that endorses H.R. 2009.
Let Freedom Ring,
July, 2013.
Dear Friend: You have no doubt heard by now that senior
members of the United States Internal Revenue Service were
involved in a politically-motivated effort to blunt the
impact of the tea party movement and other organizations not
in sync with President Barack Obama's agenda for America.
We don't yet know all the facts but we do know that some
groups had their applications for non-profit status ``slow
walked'' through the process, existing groups were subjected
to comprehensive audits, many were loaded down with intrusive
and inappropriate questions about the prayers of their
members and other activities, and that tax returns of major
donors and conservative operatives were audited.
Things are so bad that one senior IRS official who appears
to have been involved ``took the fifth'' before a
congressional investigating committee.
If that were not enough, some of the same people that look
to have been involved in the effort to politically harass
potential opponents of the president's agenda have now been
put in charge of expansion of the IRS's role in monitoring
individual and corporate compliance with Obamacare.
Our good friend Dr. Tom Price, who represents Georgia's 6th
Congressional District, is taking the bull by the horns--but
he needs our help. He has introduced a bill--H.R. 2009--that
would prohibit the Internal Revenue Service from implementing
or enforcing any provisions of the president's health care
law.
Congress needs to act--now--and they need pressure from you
to do so. They need to get behind Dr. Price's bill before the
IRS can do even more damage. Will you please take a moment to
write to your member of Congress and your two Senators and
urge them to support Dr. Price's legislation? Tell them to
cut off funding for the expansion of the IRS for Obamacare
unless and until the American people have all the answers
about how President Obama and his subordinates politicized
the IRS to harass their political opponents.
The whole business is suspicious, especially since the IRS
has for the last three years been denying to Congress that
any such activity or any activity like it was occurring.
Congress is now asking questions and the Obama Administration
has become evasive--despite a report by the IRS's own
inspector general that the agency had committed wrongdoing.
The IRS can no longer be trusted to behave in a non-
partisan manner. It should not be given extra authority until
it can prove once again that it will not abuse the public
trust.
Thank you for all you do on behalf of freedom.
Sincerely,
Colin Hanna,
President.
I'm pleased to yield 1\1/2\ minutes to a Member from the great State of Michigan, Dr. Benishek, and a fellow physician.
Mr. Speaker, I now insert into the Record a letter from the group Americans for Prosperity which endorses H.R. 2009.
Americans for Prosperity,
Arlington, VA, July 15, 2013.
Dear Representative Price: On behalf of more than two
million Americans for Prosperity activists in all 50 states,
I applaud you for introducing the Keep the IRS Off Your
Health Care Act (H.R. 2009), which would prohibit the
Internal Revenue Service from implementing the President's
health care law.
The health care law grants the IRS an alarming expansion of
new power, essentially granting the agency the authority to
oversee every American's health insurance decisions. The IRS
will be responsible for enforcing the health insurance
mandates on individuals and employers, collecting the 21 new
taxes created in the law, and cross-referencing individuals'
health insurance exchange applications with IRS records.
AFP is deeply concerned that all Americans will now be
asked to turn over the private health insurance information
about their children and families to a disgraced organization
that has admitted to abusing its power and processing
applications in a biased, political manner. How can the
American people trust that the IRS won't also target American
citizens who disagree with the President when enforcing the
health care law?
Your legislation also affirms the common-sense principle
that control over health care decisions should remain between
American families and their doctors, not Washington
bureaucrats like the IRS. Americans for Prosperity is proud
to support H.R. 2009, your legislation to prohibit the IRS
from enforcing provisions of the health care law. I urge your
colleagues to support its passage, and I look forward to
working with you in the future.
Sincerely,
Christine Harbin Hanson,
Policy Analyst, Americans for Prosperity.
Mr. Speaker, I'm pleased to yield 1\1/2\ minutes to the gentleman from Texas (Mr. Culberson), a gentleman who's a member of the Appropriations Committee, a fellow who has led on this issue for his entire career.
Mr. Speaker, I insert into the Record a letter of support for H.R. 2009 from the organization Restore America's Voice.
Restore America's Voice
Foundation,
Houston, TX, July 12, 2013.
Dear Representative Price: Our more than two million
supporters are grateful for your efforts to strip the IRS of
any authority over the Affordable Care Act as embodied in
H.R. 2009 which you have introduced. Our organization fully
endorses this legislation.
We note with discomfort that this agency seems not only
beyond the control of those tasked with oversight but
willfully resists full disclosure of questionable practices
and abusive methods in Congressional testimony. We have
concluded, based on the evidence at hand, that this agency is
being cynically used for political purposes to frustrate and
intimidate law-abiding citizens who disagree with
Administration policies.
This distortion of the proper role and functioning of the
IRS makes turning over responsibility for the Affordable Care
Act subsidies, penalties and, significantly, access to
private insurance and medical records, a frightening
prospect. We are therefore in complete agreement with the
purpose of H.R. 2009 and fully support passage as the only
responsible and prudent course of action.
Thank you for leadership and hard work in developing this
legislation and for representing the best interests of not
only your constituents but the American people.
Respectfully and gratefully yours,
Ken Hoagland,
Chairman.
Mr. Speaker, I am pleased to yield 1 minute to the gentleman from Virginia (Mr. Cantor), the majority leader of the House of Representatives.
I include for the Record a letter endorsing and supporting H.R. 2009 from the group FreedomWorks.
FreedomWorks,
Washington, DC,
Dear FreedomWorks Member: As one of our millions of
FreedomWorks members nationwide, I urge you to contact your
representative and urge him or her to co-sponsor H.R. 2009,
the ``Keep the IRS Off Your Health Care Act''. Introduced by
Rep. Tom Price (R-GA), this bill would stop the Internal
Revenue Service or any other Treasury department from
enforcing any part of ObamaCare.
Currently, the IRS will be the most crucial department for
actually enacting and enforcing ObamaCare. The premium
subsidies that are supposed to help individuals purchase
health insurance through the exchanges are actually tax
credits, distributed by the IRS. And most significantly, the
IRS is responsible for administering the ``tax'' upon
individuals who refuse to purchase a government-approved
insurance plan--the individual mandate.
More ominously, ObamaCare requires the IRS to collect a
vast amount of sensitive information about the kind of
insurance coverage you have, and will store this information
in a massive new database.
ObamaCare's supporters, of course, claim that the IRS would
never share the medical information they collect, and that
the agency would only collect the exact data necessary to
determine eligibility for premium subsidies. And yet, a
lawsuit filed in California alleges that the IRS illegally
seized the medical records of 10 million individuals in that
state.
Having the same organization that is both targeting
political opponents and stealing people's medical records in
charge of people's health care seems like a recipe for
disaster. Rep. Price's bill would stop the IRS in its tracks,
completely erasing their role in ObamaCare.
I urge you to contact your representative and urge him or
her to co-sponsor H.R. 2009, the Keep the IRS Off Your Health
Care Act today.
Sincerely,
Matt Kibbe,
President and CEO,
FreedomWorks.
Mr. Speaker, I yield 1\1/2\ minutes to the gentleman from Minnesota (Mr. Paulsen), a fellow member of the Ways and Means Committee.
Mr. Speaker, may I inquire as to the time remaining on each side?
Mr. Speaker, I'm pleased to yield 1\1/2\ minutes to the gentleman from Oklahoma (Mr. Bridenstine), a freshman Member.
Mr. Speaker, I appreciate the comments from my friend from Wisconsin. His chastising us for voting to repeal or change portions of the Affordable Care Act is curious, in light of the fact that the gentleman, himself, I believe, supported one of our efforts just 2 weeks ago on delaying the employer mandate. But hope springs eternal that he'll be able to support our efforts in this endeavor on
Mr. Speaker, I will insert a letter in support of H.R. 2009 from the Americans for Tax Reform into the Record.
I reserve the balance of my time.
[From Americans for Tax Reform, June 20, 2013]
ATR Supports H.R. 2009, the ``Keep the IRS Off Your Health Care Act of
2013''
(By Ryan Ellis)
ATR supports H.R. 2009, the ``Keep the IRS Off Your Health
Care Act of 2013,'' sponsored by Cong. Tom Price (R-Ga.)
ATR is pleased to announce its support for H.R.. 2009, the
``Keep the IRS Off Your Health Care Act of 2013.'' The bill
is sponsored by medical doctor and Congressman Tom Price (R-
Ga.) We would urge all Congressmen to co-sponsor and support
the bill.
GAO has reported that there are 47 new powers the IRS has
acquired under the Obamacare law. We here at ATR have pointed
out time and again the 20 new or higher taxes that are
contained in Obamacare. With a new scandal coming out of the
IRS seemingly every day, the last thing that agency should be
doing is snooping into the personal health care lives of over
300 million Americans.
Yet that's just what the IRS is about to do. They will be
the agency tasked with implementing the individual mandate
and the employer mandate. They will force all of us to
disclose our personal health identification information to
them when we file our 1040s every April. They will be talking
to our insurance companies and the Department of Health and
Human Services about our health insurance packages.
This is outrageous. The IRS should have nothing to do with
our health care. Passage of H.R.. 2009 would ensure that the
agency which gave us Star Trek videos and Tea Party
harassment keeps its hands off our health care.
Mr. Speaker, I will include into the Record a letter endorsing H.R. 2009 from a group of six taxpayer advocate organizations.
Mr. Speaker, I reserve the balance of my time.
August 2, 2013.
Hon. Tom Price,
Cannon House Office Building,
Washington, DC.
Dear Representative Price, We the undersigned groups,
representing millions of Americans, strongly support your
legislation, H.R. 2009, the Keep the IRS Off Your Health Care
Act of 2013. This bill would prohibit the U.S. Treasury
Department from enforcing any provision of the Affordable
Care Act (aka Obamacare), ensuring that the Internal Revenue
Service (IRS) would be removed from implementing or enforcing
any component of Obamacare.
The last several months have proven to be an eye opening
experience for those who are concerned with the growing power
of the federal government, especially the IRS. Repeated and
systemic encroachment into the lives of American citizens by
targeting the very thing they cherish the most, the freedom
of speech, is a cause of great concern among many people from
all sides of the political spectrum. It is imperative to take
steps to ensure we rein in the power of an organization that
has proven to be incapable of handling the authority they
have right now with the responsibility and dignity the
American people expect. New developments on the unnerving
offenses have been uncovered on a regular basis for the last
few months and it is time to make certain that the IRS is
unable to extend these offenses into the lives of citizens
when it comes to their health care.
This legislation makes explicitly clear that the neither
the Treasury Department, nor ``any delegate'' shall have the
power to enforce any provision or amendment from Obamacare at
anytime going forward as the Administration moves to
implement the law. It is paramount that this legislation
passes, with overwhelming support, as it is clear that the
American people have no desire to have the IRS involved in
the decisions they and their families are making when it
comes to their health care. We have already seen the
consequences of the President's health care law on premiums
and job creation and it would be catastrophic to allow the
IRS to contribute to the chaos, considering their recent
record of abuses and mismanagement.
The American people deserve to be trusted with their own
decision making when it comes to their lives, including their
health care choices. The last thing anyone wants is to have
an agency they are already afraid of to be granted more.
We thank you for offering this commonsense language and we
urge all members of Congress to vote ``yes'' on H.R. 2009.
Sincerely,
David Williams,
President, Taxpayers Protection Alliance.
Grover Norquist,
President, Americans for Tax Reform.
Jeff Mazzella,
President, Center for Individual Freedom.
Carrie Lukas,
Managing Director, Independent Women's Forum.
Seton Motley,
President, Less Government.
Pete Sepp,
Executive Vice President, National Taxpayers Union.
Mr. Speaker, I would tell the gentleman that I have other speakers that may be coming, but at this point, I have no other speakers on the floor. I am prepared to close at any point.
Mr. Speaker, I continue to reserve the balance of my time.
I continue to reserve the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, I will submit a letter from 22 organizations from around the country endorsing H.R. 2009, and I reserve the balance of my time.
August 1, 2013.
Dear Congressmen: We, the undersigned organizations and
free market leaders write in united support of House efforts
this week to get the IRS out of Obamacare.
The House will consider a measure on Friday sponsored by
Congressman Tom Price (R-Ga.) to remove the IRS from any role
in the implementation of the Obamacare law.
It's a basic belief of most Americans that patients,
families, and doctors--not IRS bureaucrats--should be making
health care decisions. While this has always been the case,
its importance has been heightened in recent months by the
uncovered political targeting by the IRS of Tea Party and
other free market groups. The IRS should not be anywhere near
people's medical decisions until this black cloud of
political scandal has been lifted.
Unfortunately, the GAO reports that the IRS has no fewer
than 47 powers to implement Obamacare. That's 47 too many.
Allowing the IRS to enforce Obamacare is opening up the door
to more abuse, more targeting, and more harassment of
American citizens. The myriad of new taxes the IRS will
impose under the guise of health care reform will destroy
jobs, stifle economic growth, and impede medical innovation
in this country.
With Obamacare coming fully online in 2014, now is the time
to stop the IRS from becoming a full partner in our families'
healthcare decisions. House efforts to prevent this from
happening are welcome and all Members of Congress should
support these efforts.
Sincerely,
Grover Norquist, Americans for Tax Reform; Dean Clancy,
Freedom Works; Al Cardenas, American Conservative
Union; Amy Kremer, Tea Party Express; Jenny Beth
Martin, Tea Party Patriots; Heather Higgins,
Independent Womens' Voice; Steven J. Duffield,
Crossroads GPS; Brandon Arnold, National Taxpayers
Union; Colin Hanna, Let Freedom Ring; Jim Martin, 60
Plus Association; Grace-Marie Turner, Galen Institute;
Phil Kerpen, American Commitment; Penny Nance,
Concerned Women for America; Ken Hoagland, Restore
America's Voice; John Tate, Campaign for Liberty; Peter
Ferrara, National Center for Policy Analysis; Ari
Winkour, Harbour League; Gregory T. Angelo, Log Cabin
Republicans; Mark Schiller, MD, Doctor-Patient Medical
Association; Betsy McCaughey, Ph.D, author of Beating
Obamacare; Brian Baker, Ending Spending; David Wallace,
Restore America's Mission.
(Signatures are for information purposes only).
Mr. Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may consume.
Again, it's important for folks to appreciate that the Republican goal in health care is to make certain that every single American has the highest quality health care. We simply believe it ought to be patient-centered health care. And my friends on the other side of the aisle talk about patient-centered health care, but what they support is health care with Washington making decisions. We believe patients and families and doctors ought to be making medical decisions.
Now, what have we heard in opposition to this piece of legislation today? We've heard that Republicans have no plan. Well, on the contrary, Mr. Speaker, we have multiple pieces of legislation. I, in fact, have H.R. 2300, which is a patient-centered bill that makes certain that everybody has affordable coverage; that they are able to have the financial feasibility to purchase the coverage that they want, not that the government forces them to buy. And portability is solved. You don't lose your insurance if you change your job or you lose your job. We solve the whole challenge of preexisting illnesses and injuries, but in a patient-centered way, not a way that the government forces you to purchase what they want you to purchase. And it would provide insurance for every single American.
Second, we've heard this isn't a responsible piece of legislation. Mr. Speaker, let me suggest that the American people think this is a responsible piece of legislation, where over 80 percent don't think the IRS ought to have a thing to do with their health care.
We've heard that this bill isn't going anywhere at all. Why do it? It's a futile attempt. Well, I'll remind my colleagues of seven pieces of legislation--bills passed in this House, bills passed by the United States Senate, and signed into law by President Obama--that either repealed or defunded portions of his own health care law.
H.R. 4 repealed the small business paperwork mandate; H.R. 1473 cut $2.2 billion from the ``stealth public plan'' and froze the IRS budget; H.R. 674 saved taxpayers $13 billion by adjusting eligibility for ObamaCare programs; H.R. 2055 made more reductions to the Independent Payment Advisory Board and the IRS; H.R. 3630 slashed billions of dollars from ObamaCare slush funds; H.R. 4348 saved another $670 million from the boondoggle, ``the Louisiana Purchase,'' that was included in the original bill; and H.R. 8 repealed the unsustainable CLASS programs.
All of those repealed or changed portions of the Affordable Care Act signed into law by the President of the United States.
We've heard heart-wrenching stories from our friends on the other side about health challenges and illnesses. And, yes, Mr. Speaker, there are real challenges out there. As a physician, I can attest to that, having spent over 20 years taking care of patients. But the American people don't want Washington deciding what kind of health care they must have or can't have. We need patients and families and doctors making those medical decisions.
And then there's the preposterous assertion from the other side that Republicans don't like affordable care, quality care, accessible care. Nonsense, Mr. Speaker. Nonsense. What we want is the highest quality of care that respects the principles of affordability and accessibility and quality and choices and responsiveness and innovation. We simply want patients and families and doctors to be in charge of health care, not Washington, D.C., and not the IRS.
I urge support of H.R. 2009, and I yield back the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, I reserve a point of order against the motion to recommit.