Mr. President, I wish to acknowledge the life and the courage of Hugh Patterson, who died last week at the age of 91. Mr. Patterson was the publisher of the Arkansas Gazette in 1957 when the Arkansas National Guard was called up to prevent…
Mr. President, I wish to acknowledge the life and the courage of Hugh Patterson, who died last week at the age of 91. Mr. Patterson was the publisher of the Arkansas Gazette in 1957 when the Arkansas National Guard was called up to prevent nine young Blacks from enrolling at Central High School in Little Rock. This hugely divisive issue not only had to be reported on in the Gazette, it had to be evaluated on the editorial page. Mr. Patterson's initial reaction was the right one; support desegregation. He later recalled that he said, ``Well, of course, it's got to be recognized that the Supreme Court decision was the only decision that could have been made. We have to recognize that this is a transitional time in terms of public policy and it will, perhaps, take some time for that to be realized, but there's just no option to this. It's a fundamental matter.'' Mr. Patterson was the paper's first publisher, responsible for policy as well as business, but he was not the only one making major editorial decisions. He had to help convince the owner, his father-in-law, J.N. Heiskell, and he did.
The reaction to the newspaper's stand for desegregation was severe. There were boycotts against advertisers and mobs out to prevent delivery trucks from delivering papers. Circulation fell. The financial losses were significant, and harmful on a larger scale because Mr. Patterson's philosophy was that profits should be put back into the paper, which he saw as a public service to the State. The Gazette won two Pulitzer Prizes for its coverage in 1957 and they were well deserved. As today's Democrat-Gazette
said last week, ``Dante reserved a special place in his Inferno for those who would stay neutral in times of moral crisis. No one need bother looking for the Arkansas Gazette there. Fully aware that his paper had much to lose, Hugh Patterson never hesitated to stake it all on what he knew to be right.''
Mr. Patterson grew up in Pine Bluff and learned the printing business. After serving in the Army Air Corps in World War II, he joined the Gazette in 1946. He became publisher in 1948 and stayed in that job for 38 years. There was much more to his career there than the events of 1957, and to fill in those details I ask that his obituary from the Democrat-Gazette be printed after my remarks. Arkansas is much the better for his voice in a time of crisis and his many other contributions at the helm of the Gazette for so many years.
The material follows.
[From the Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, May 30, 2006]
Hugh Patterson, Chief of Arkansas Gazette for 38 years, Dies at 91
(By Noel E. Oman)
Hugh B. Patterson Jr., the longtime publisher of the former
Arkansas Gazette, died Monday. He was 91.
Patterson was publisher of the Gazette from November 1948
until December 1986, when the newspaper was sold to Gannett
Co. Inc. Patterson's 38 years directing the ``oldest
newspaper west of the Mississippi'' began in the era of the
mechanical typesetting machine and lasted into the age of
computer-generated print.
His tenure coincided with Little Rock's public school
desegregation crisis in 1957. The Gazette won two Pulitzer
Prizes in 1958, one to the newspaper for public service and
the other to Executive Editor Harry S. Ashmore for editorial
writing.
``This first thing I think of, as you might guess, is the
1957 school crisis, and the Gazette's performance through
that period,'' said Roy Reed, professor emeritus of
journalism at the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville.
Reed was a reporter at the Gazette for eight years, later
joining The New York Times as a national and foreign
correspondent.
``It's not fully appreciated outside of a very small group
the role Hugh Patterson had. He was absolutely vital to
leading the paper to the position it held: Obey the law and
the court decision,'' Reed said.
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette Publisher Walter E. Hussman Jr.
said Monday that Patterson should be remembered for his
leadership of the Gazette ``during its greatest years,'' in
the late 1950s.
``It was a difficult time, and he certainly responded,''
Hussman said.
Al Neuharth, who founded USA Today and helped build the
Gannett newspaper empire that purchased the Gazette, said he
was sorry to hear of Patterson's death.
``He was considered by all of us who knew him as a real
Southern gentleman, real dedicated newspaper person and I
considered him a good friend,'' Neuharth said. ``He did a lot
for the state of Arkansas.''
Patterson was born on Feb. 8, 1915, in Cotton Plant, Miss.
He came to Arkansas with his family in 1917. He was educated
in the public schools of Pine Bluff and at Henderson State
Teachers College, now Henderson State University, in
Arkadelphia. He also did special studies in graphic arts and
advertising in Washington, D.C., and New York.
He married the former Louise Heiskell of Little Rock on
March 29, 1944. His wife was the daughter of J.N. Heiskell,
who was president and editor of the Gazette from 1902 until
his death in 1972. The Pattersons had two sons, Carrick H.
Patterson and Ralph B. Patterson, both of Little Rock.
Ralph Patterson said Monday that his father emphasized
putting profits back into the newspaper. ``That was very
important to him: That the paper not be a cash cow, but a
public service to the state.''
Before World War II, Patterson worked primarily in the
commercial printing business in Pine Bluff, Little Rock, New
York and Washington. His first job in the field was at Adams
Lithographic and Printing Co. of Pine Bluff when ``I was
about 14 or 15, I suppose,'' Patterson recalled in a 2000
interview with Roy Reed, who is also director of the Arkansas
Gazette Project at the University of Arkansas. The project is
an effort to collect and preserve the newspaper's history.
``The Depression was coming on and they had to cut down on
staff some... so I melted type metal and washed the platen
presses, and I was the shipping clerk,'' Patterson said.
After dropping out of Henderson State because his family
didn't have enough money, Patterson purchased his first car,
a 1931 Chevrolet for $75, on credit, and traveled the roads
of south Arkansas and north Louisiana selling printing
supplies for the Smith Co., another Pine Bluff printing firm,
according to the Reed interview.
In 1936, he moved to Little Rock to work for Democrat
Printing and Lithograph Co., where he earned $20 a week.
Patterson served in the Army Air Corps in World War II, for
the most part, in Mobile, Ala., where he specialized in
supply and maintenance management. He left the service with
the rank of major.
Patterson pondered forming a management consulting company
when the war ended. But during a weekend trip to Little Rock,
he had dinner with his father-in-law, who appreciated his
printing background.
Heiskell, whose son had died in the war, had a proposition.
``Mr. Heiskell said, `You are the only one with related
experience and as soon as you can get out, I'd like for you
to come to the paper,''' Patterson recalled in the Reed
interview.
Patterson joined the Gazette as national advertising
manager in 1946. Two years later, Heiskell made him the
newspaper's first publisher, responsible for policy as well
as the business. Before that, the Gazette had a business
manager to run the business and an editor who was responsible
for newspaper policy.
James O. Powell, the Gazette's editorial page editor from
1959-1986, said Patterson recruited him from the Tampa
Tribune. ``He was an excellent publisher, a good businessman,
who knew the newspaper industry well indeed,'' Powell said.
Patterson ``knew well the pursuit of the public interest
using the newspaper.''
On the business side, Patterson consolidated the ownership
of the Gazette under the Heiskell family and successfully
fought off an attempt by financier Witt Stephens, who owned
Gazette stock, to obtain a controlling interest, a move that
Patterson enjoyed retelling to Reed.
``He thought I was a yokel,'' Patterson recalled, laughing.
``I suppose that was the best poker hand I ever played.''
Patterson, relying on his experience in commercial
printing, also developed financial controls that showed the
relationship between costs and revenue, which he found few in
the industry knew.
``It was absolutely new,'' Patterson told Reed. ``And so I
developed this thing, and I wrote a paper on it, and it was
adopted by the Institute of Newspaper Controllers and Finance
Officers.''
The Gazette's controller, Jack Olsen, a former Internal
Revenue Service accountant, fine-tuned Patterson's accounting
system. Olsen eventually went to work for the St. Petersburg
Times, The New York Times and the Chicago Tribune, using the
budgeting process Patterson developed.
Patterson also organized the newspaper into more sections,
added stock tables, more news services and beefed up the
Sunday newspaper with the addition of color comics and Parade
Magazine.
On policy, it was Patterson who set the Gazette on the
course that won it the Pulitzer.
Patterson was a regional chairman of the National Council
for Public Schools when he was interviewed by a reporter for
The Associated Press about implementing the May 17, 1954,
U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Brown v. Board of Education,
which found that segregation in schools was inherently
unequal and in violation of the Constitution.
``I said, 'Well, of course, it's got to be recognized that
the Supreme Court decision was the only decision that could
have been made,'' Patterson recalled. ``We have to recognize
that this is a transitional time in terms of public policy
and it will, perhaps, take some time for that to be realized,
but there's just no option to this. It's a fundamental
matter.'''
A wire service story containing those quotes appeared in
the Gazette. Upon returning to Arkansas, Executive Editor
Ashmore wondered whether Heiskell would fire Patterson,
Patterson said. About a week later, the subject came up with
Heiskell, who was over at the Patterson home to visit his
grandchildren. Patterson said he told him, ``Well, you know,
deep down we're talking about your grandchildren's
generation. And we feel that we can't misrepresent these
issues to them. We can't bring them up feeling that what is
inevitable is not true.''
``That was the last time it was ever discussed,'' Patterson
told Reed. ``And when Ashmore heard about that, for the first
time, he was able to deal more realistically with the
question textually in the editorials.''
Jim Johnson, a former associate justice of the Arkansas
Supreme Court and the Democratic Party nominee for governor
in 1966--and no favorite of the Arkansas Gazette's editorial
page--said his battles with the Gazette over segregation
amounted to a ``political vendetta.'' But he said he always
respected and admired Patterson's civility and tenacity.
``He was a master at his craft and a worthy, worthy
adversary. He was keenly effective. You had to admire it. As
my daddy would say, he learned me something.''
Arkansas Times columnist and former Gazette employee Ernie
Dumas said Patterson never really got credit for his role in
1957 and 1958, critical years for the Gazette and the state.
``Everybody has also attributed the heroism and courage to
Heiskell and Ashmore. Hugh played a very strong role in
bringing Harry and Heiskell around, that despite the peril to
the Gazette, they should take a stand against Orval Faubus.''
By the mid-1980s, Patterson and the Gazette began feeling
pressure from the Arkansas Democrat, a newspaper that the
Walter E. Hussman family had acquired in 1974 and converted
from an afternoon daily to a morning newspaper to compete
head-to-head with the Gazette. In the early 1980s, he met
with representatives of Times-Mirror Corp. and the New York
Times Co. in an effort to sell the paper to a company that
could allow the Gazette to continue publishing.
Unable to find a suitor, the Gazette filed a federal
lawsuit accusing the Democrat of
predatory practices. The Democrat contended that it resorted
to innovative but legal business practices because the
Gazette was the dominant paper. In March 1986, a jury found
in favor of the Democrat.
Patterson sold the Gazette to the Gannett Co. a short time
later, and often professed unhappiness with the changes the
national chain made to the state's ``gray lady.''
On Oct. 18, 1991, Gannett shut down the Gazette and sold
the Gazette's assets and name to Little Rock Newspapers Inc.,
now called Arkansas Democrat-Gazette Inc. The company is a
corporate subsidiary of WEHCO Media Inc. whose chief
executive officer, Walter E. Hussman Jr., is publisher of the
Arkansas Democrat-Gazette, which began publishing under that
name on Oct. 19, 1991.
Throughout his newspaper career, Patterson was active in
civic affairs. He was a member of the Little Rock Planning
Commission for 20 years. In 1957, Patterson helped initiate
the city manager form of government for Little Rock. He also
helped create the Metropolitan Area Planning Commission, now
known as Metroplan.
Patterson was awarded the Freedom House Freedom Award in
1958 and the Arkansas Council of the National Conference of
Christians and Jews Humanitarian Award in 1987. Also in 1987,
Patterson was named Arkansas Journalist of the Year by the
University of Arkansas at Little Rock. Patterson also served
as president of the Southern Newspaper Publishers
Association.