Mr. Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may consume. Mr. Speaker, H.R. 1913 establishes the Clear Creek National Recreation Area and the Joaquin Rocks Wilderness Area on land administered by the Bureau of Land Management in the central…
Mr. Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may consume.
Mr. Speaker, H.R. 1913 establishes the Clear Creek National Recreation Area and the Joaquin Rocks Wilderness Area on land administered by the Bureau of Land Management in the central coast region of California. From hiking and hunting to off-highway vehicle use, those designations will improve and enhance access for a variety of recreational activities, while ensuring that ecologically sensitive and unique areas are managed in a way that supports their lasting and permanent protection.
In addition to the many ecological benefits they provide, including clean air and clean water, wilderness areas throughout the country play a large role in supporting the approximately $646 billion per year outdoor recreation economy, so I am pleased that we are advancing this bill to add 21,000 acres of the National Wilderness Preservation System.
This bill has strong local support from San Benito County government officials and a number of off-highway vehicle and wilderness groups. These advocates understand that Clear Creek is important to the economy, and they have fond memories of the recreational opportunities when they were younger.
I have received numerous support comments from my constituents, the off-highway vehicle community, and other California residents about the importance of Clear Creek to their family and how the closure has impacted them. It is time to honor the desire of my constituents in California's 20th Congressional District and pass this bill once again.
Mr. Speaker, I include in the Record letters in support of the bill.
San Benito County,
Hollister, CA, June 1, 2017.
Re Letter in Support of H.R. 1913.
Hon. Jimmy Panetta,
House of Representatives,
Washington, DC.
Dear Representative Panetta: I would like to express my
support of proposed legislation H.R. 1913. On at least three
previous occasions, the San Benito County Board of
Supervisors has formally expressed their support of this
proposed measure in the form of H.R. 1776 as submitted by
then-Congressman Sam Farr.
As background, the Serpentine Area of Critical
Environmental Concern (ACEC) of the Clear Creek Management
Area (CCMA) was closed in 2008 based on a study by the EPA
which concluded that naturally occurring asbestos (NOA) posed
a public health risk. However, in 2010, the Off Highway Motor
Vehicle Recreation (OHMVR) Division of the State of
California Department of Parks and Recreation Commissioned an
independent OHV-specific risk assessment of NOA exposure
within the Serpentine ACEC of the CCMA.
This report, completed by the International Environmental
Research Foundation (IERF), concluded that management and
operation strategies could be employed to allow for off-
highway vehicle (OHV) recreation in the CCMA without exposing
the public to higher than acceptable levels of NOA and
without presenting a serious risk to human health.
Specifically, the risk of OHV usage five days per year, for
eight hours on each of those days, was equated to being
similar to the lifetime risk of smoking less than one
cigarette one the same one year period, and the report noted
that other recreational activities, such as swimming, hiking
and snow skiing, are over 100 times more dangerous.
In light of this report which directly contradicts the
conclusions of the EPA study and undermines the necessity of
BLM actions taken since 2008 in reliance of that study, it
would appear that closure of the ACEC is not scientifically
warranted, and especially not during winter months when dust
from OHV activity is greatly reduced.
Therefore, the County supports opening the area to OHV
users once again and allowing the public access to this
natural area which is easily accessible to the urban
residents in the San Jose/San Francisco metropolitan areas.
H.R. 1913, which would establish the Clear Creek National
Recreation Area in San Benito and Fresno Counties, is
essential to enhancing public access to natural and scenic
areas within our State.
The lack of evidence of a serious health risk is reinforced
by the fact that there is
the lack of any documented case of any person, whether
recreational, visitor or governmental employee, injured by
NOA within the ACEC despite the use of the area for decades.
Therefore, the activities taken to close the area are
especially troubling considering the effect of the closure on
the public generally, as well as the local economy.
Access to recreational areas within San Benito County,
including the CCMA, provides a necessary and substantial
component to the local economy which has been drastically
affected by the recent economic climate. The BLM's past
decision to close the Clear Creek area has already seriously
affected San Benito County's economic vitality. The County
could understand such action if there was truly a serious
health risk presented by use of the CCMA, but there is no
generally accepted scientific evidence, especially during
wetter winter months.
The Clear Creek Management Area was among the five most
popular areas cited by California off-highway-vehicle (OHV)
users in a 1990 study conducted by the California Department
of Parks and Recreation. Many of these users were residents
of the San Jose and San Francisco Bay. In 2003 and 2004,
there were an estimated 50,000 visitors to the CCMA, largely
attributable to allowed OHV usage.
In conclusion, the Board of Supervisors supports the
proposed legislation, as well as designation of the Clear
Creek Management Area as a National Recreation Area,
designation of OHV recreation as a ``prescribed use'' within
the National Recreation Area, and providing that the
management plan of the Clear Creek National Recreation Area,
including OHV routes, open areas, number of permitted OHV
events and other recreational activities should be as set
forth in the 2005 Clear Creek Travel Management Plan.
Thank you for your consideration of this letter.
Respectfully,
Jerry Muenzer,
Supervisor District 4,
Board of Supervisors.
Mr. Speaker, this is a bipartisan bill, and I thank Chairman Bishop and Ranking Member Grijalva for their leadership, their work, and assistance in getting this bill to the floor of the House of Representatives. I also thank Representatives David Valadao, Jeff Denham, and Paul Cook, as well as my predecessor, Representative Sam Farr, and our staffs for their work on this bill.
Mr. Speaker, I urge quick adoption of this legislation, and I yield back the balance of my time.