Mr. Speaker, I yield 4 minutes to the gentleman from Rhode Island (Mr. Cicilline), my very good friend. Mr. Speaker, I yield an additional 30 seconds to the gentleman from Rhode Island. Mr. Speaker, I include in the Record a list of over…
Mr. Speaker, I yield 4 minutes to the gentleman from Rhode Island (Mr. Cicilline), my very good friend.
Mr. Speaker, I yield an additional 30 seconds to the gentleman from Rhode Island.
Mr. Speaker, I include in the Record a list of over 270 organizations opposed to the balanced budget amendment.
National Organization Opposing the Balanced Budget Amendment
9to5, National Association of Working Women; AASA, The
School Superintendents Association; Academy of Nutrition and
Dietetics; ADAP Advocacy Association (aaa+);
Advance CTE; Advocates for Youth; African American Health
Alliance; AIDS Alliance for Women, Infants, Children, Youth &
Families; AIDS Community Research Initiative of America; AIDS
United; Alaska Wilderness League; Alliance for a Just Society
D535; Alliance for Excellent Education; Alliance for Justice;
Alliance for Retired Americans; Alliance for Strong Families
and Communities; American Association for Dental Research;
American Association for Justice; American Association of
Colleges for Teacher Education; American Association of
University Women (AAUW).
American Council on Education; American Counseling
Association; American Dance Therapy Association; American
Federation of Government Employees, AFL-CIO; American
Federation of Labor (AFL-CIO); American Federation of School
Administrators (AFSA); American Federation of State, County
and Municipal Employees (AFSCME); American Federation of
Teachers, AFL-CIO; American Indian Higher Education
Consortium; American Jewish Committee (AJC); American Music
Therapy Association; American Network of Community Options
and Resources (ANCOR); American Postal Workers Union, AFL-
CIO; American Public Health Association; American School
Counselor Association; American Speech-Language-Hearing
Association; Americans for Democratic Action (ADA); Asian &
Pacific Islander American Health Forum (APIAHF); Asian
Americans Advancing Justice--AAJC; Asian Pacific American
Labor Alliance, AFL-CIO (APALA); Association for Career and
Technical Education.
Association for Psychological Science; Association of
Assistive Technology Act Programs (ATAP); Association of
Educational Service Agencies; Association of Farmworker
Opportunity Programs; Association of Flight Attendants--CWA;
Association of School Business Officials International
(ASBO); Association of University Centers on Disabilities
(AUCD); Asthma and Allergy Foundation of America; Autism
National Committee; Autistic Self Advocacy Network; Bazelon
Center for Mental Health Law; Bienestar Human Services; B'nai
B'rith International; Bread for the World; Campaign for
America's Future; Campaign for Youth Justice; Catholics in
Alliance for the Common Good; Center for Community Change
Action; Center for Family Policy and Practice Center for Law
and Social Policy (CLASP).
Center for Medicare Advocacy, Inc.; Center for Public
Representation; Center for Science in the Public Interest;
Center on Budget and Policy Priorities; Child Care Aware of
America; Child Welfare League of America; Children's Action
Alliance; Children's Defense Fund; Children's Dental Health
Project; Children's Health Watch; Children's Leadership
Council; Citizens for Tax Justice; Clinical Social Work
Association; Coalition for Health Funding; Coalition on Human
Needs; Commission on Adult Basic Education (COABE); Committee
for Education Funding; Common Cause; Communications Workers
of America (CWA).
Community Access National Network (CANN); Community Action
Partnership; Community Anti-Drug Coalitions of America
(CADCA); Concerned Black Men National; Conservation Legacy;
Corporation for Enterprise Development (CFED); Corporation
for Supportive Housing; CoSN--the Consortium for School
Networking; Council for Exceptional Children; Council for
Opportunity in Education; Council of Administrators of
Special Education, Inc.; Council of the Great City
Schools; CREDOCriminalization of Poverty Project at the
Institute for Policy Studies; Defenders of Wildlife;
Democracy 21; Demos; Department for Professional
Employees, AFL-CIO; Disability Rights Education and
Defense Fund; Disciples Justice Action Network; Easter
Seals.
Ecumenical Poverty Initiative; Every Child Matters;
FamiliesUSA; Farmworker Justice; Feeding America; First Focus
Campaign for Children; Food & Water Watch; Food Research &
Action Center (FRAC); Foster Family-based Treatment
Association; Franciscan Action Network; Franciscans for
Justice; Friends Committee on National Legislation; Friends
of the Earth; Futures Without Violence; Gamaliel; Gay Men's
Health Crisis (GMHC); Generations United; Global Justice
Institute; Health Care for America Now (HCAN); Health GAP
(Global Access Project).
Higher Education Consortium for Special Education; Housing
Works; Institute on Taxation and Economic Policy; Interfaith
Worker Justice; International Association of Fire Fighters;
International Association of Machinists and Aerospace
Workers; International Brotherhood of Boilermakers;
International Brotherhood of Teamsters; International
Federation of Professional & Technical Engineers (IFPTE),
AFL-CIO; International Union, United Automobile, Aerospace
and Agricultural Implement Workers of America, UAW;
International Society for Technology in Education (ISTE);
Jewish Council for Public Affairs; Jobs With Justice; Justice
in Aging; LeadingAge; League of Conservation Voters; League
of United Latin American Citizens; League of Women Voters of
the United States; Learning Disabilities Association of
America; Main Street Alliance.
Medical Mission Sisters, North America; Medicare Rights
Center; Mental Health America; Metropolitan Community
Churches; Mom2Mom Global; MomsRising; NAACP; NASTAD (National
Alliance of State & Territorial AIDS Directors); National
Academy of Elder Law Attorneys; National Active and Retired
Federal Employees Association (NARFE); National Advocacy
Center of the Sisters of the Good Shepherd; National Alliance
for Partnerships in Equity (NAPE); National Alliance of HUD
Tenants; National Alliance to End Sexual Violence; National
Asian Pacific American Women's Forum; National Association
for Children's Behavioral Health; National Association for
College Admission Counseling; National Association for
Hispanic Elderly; National Association for Music Education;
National Association for the Education of Young Children.
National Association of Area Agencies on Aging (n4a);
National Association of Councils on Developmental
Disabilities; National Association of County and City Health
Officials; National Association of County Behavioral Health
and Developmental Disability Directors; National Association
of Elementary School Principals; National Association of
Federally Impacted Schools; National Association of Letter
Carriers; National Association of Private Special Education
Centers; National Association of School Psychologists;
National Association of Secondary School Principals; National
Association of Social Workers (NASW); National Association of
State Directors of Special Education; National Association of
State Head Injury Administrators; National Birth Defects
Prevention Network; National Black Justice Coalition;
National Center for Law and Economic Justice; National Center
on Domestic and Sexual Violence; National Coalition Against
Domestic Violence.
National Coalition for Asian Pacific American Community
Development (National CAPACD); National Committee to Preserve
Social Security and Medicare; National Community Development
Association; National Congress of American Indians; National
Council for Behavioral Health; National Council for Community
and Education Partnerships; National Council of Asian Pacific
Americans; National Council of Jewish Women; National Council
of La Raza (NCLR); National Council on Independent Living;
National Disability Institute; National Disability Rights
Network; National Domestic Violence Hotline; National Down
Syndrome Congress; National Education Association (NEA);
National Employment Law Project; National Fair Housing
Alliance; National Federation of Federal Employees; National
Health Care for the Homeless Council; National Hispanic
Medical Association.
National Housing Law Project; National Housing Trust;
National Immigration Law Center; National Latina Institute
for Reproductive Health; National LGBTQ Task Force Action
Fund; National Low Income Housing Coalition; National
Multiple Sclerosis Society; National Network to End Domestic
Violence; National Organization for Women; National
Partnership for Women & Families; National People's Action;
National Priorities Project; National PTA; National
Recreation and Park Association; National Respite Coalition;
National Rural Education Advocacy Coalition; National Rural
Education Association; National School Boards Association;
National Skills Coalition; National Superintendents
Roundtable.
National Treasury Employees Union; NATIONAL URBAN LEAGUE;
National Viral Hepatitis Roundtable; National WIC
Association; National Women's Health Network; National
Women's Law Center; National Working Positive Coalition;
Natural Resources Defense Council; NDD United; Network for
Environmental & Economic Responsibility of United Church of
Christ; NETWORK: A National Catholic Social Justice Lobby;
Not Dead Yet; OWL-The Voice of Women 40+; PAI; Paralyzed
Veterans of America; Partnership for America's Children;
People for the American Way; PICO National Network; Planned
Parenthood Federation of America; Prevention Institute.
Professional Aviation Safety Specialists (PASS);
Progressive Congress; Project Inform; ProLiteracy; Protect
All Children's Environment; Public Advocacy for Kids; Public
Citizen; Public Health Institute; Racial and Ethnic Health
Disparities Coalition; RESULTS; Sargent Shriver National
Center on Poverty Law; School Social Work Association of
America; School-Based Health Alliance; Senior Executives
Association (SEA); Service Employees International Union
(SEIU); Share Our Strength; Sinsinawa Dominican Peace and
Justice Office; Sisters of Charity of Nazareth Congregational
Leadership; Sisters of Charity of Nazareth Western Province
Leadership; Sisters of Mercy South Central Community.
Social Security Works; Southeast Asia Resource Action
Center (SEARAC); Special Needs Alliance; State Innovation
Exchange (SiX); Stewards of Affordable Housing for the
Future; Susan G. Komen; TESOL International Association; The
AIDS Institute; The Arc; The Leadership Conference on Civil
and Human Rights; The National Coalition for Literacy; The
National Crittenton Foundation; The Sisters of Mercy of the
Americas, Institute Justice Team; The United Methodist
Church--General Board of Church and Society; Transportation
Trades Department, AFL-CIO; Treatment Action Group (TAG);
Tremor Action Network; Trust for America's Health (TFAH);
UNCF; Union for Reform Judaism.
United Auto Workers (UAW); United Cerebral Palsy; United
Church of Christ Justice and Witness Ministries; United
Spinal Association; United States Student Association (USSA);
United Steelworkers (USW); USAction; Voices for Progress;
Women's Institute for a Secure Retirement (WISER);
Young Invincibles; YouthBuild USA; ZERO TO THREE.
Mr. Speaker, I yield 5 minutes to the gentlewoman from Florida (Mrs. Murphy), my good friend.
Mr. Speaker, how much time is remaining on each side?
Mr. Speaker, I yield myself such time as I may consume.
Mr. Speaker, I include in the Record two letters: one from AFSCME and one from AARP.
American Federation of State, County and Municipal
Employees, AFL-CIO,
Washington, DC, April 10, 2018.
House of Representatives,
Washington, DC.
Dear Representative: On behalf of the 1.6 million members
of the American Federation of State, County and Municipal
Employees (AFSCME), I am writing to urge you to vote no on
H.J. Res. 2 and to reject this and any other effort to amend
the U.S. Constitution to require a balanced budget.
The proposed constitutional amendment is a draconian and
unwise proposal that would damage the economy, result in huge
job losses and weaken vital public services that all
Americans depend upon. It unwisely requires outlays to match
receipts each year regardless of economic conditions, a
supermajority vote of three-fifths to increase the debt
ceiling with limited exceptions for outlays to exceed
receipts only in times of war, but not during recessions or
disasters.
H.J. Res. 2 is a false attempt to claim fiscal
responsibility on the heels of a reckless tax cut that is
projected to cause the deficit to skyrocket to $1.9 trillion
over the next decade, according to the Congressional Budget
Office (CBO), and to exceed $2.5 trillion if its tax policies
are extended. The tax cut for the wealthy and big
corporations irresponsibly forced revenues to their lowest
levels since 1956, an unsustainable level far below what is
needed to support programs that provide basic needs for
struggling families, to promote economic growth and meet
other critical needs like investing in infrastructure and
education.
H.J. Res. 2 would irresponsibly require a supermajority
vote to lift the debt ceiling, an already difficult vote that
subjects the U.S. and worldwide economies to instability and
potential economic destruction. Further, requiring a balanced
budget annually would take away the ability to respond to
changing economic conditions and raise serious risks of
tipping weak economies into recession and making recessions
longer and deeper. Most egregious, H.J. Res. 2 is a thinly
veiled attempt to force drastic changes to Social Security,
Medicare, Medicaid and veterans' benefits that Americans earn
and depend on.
H.J. Res. 2 is a dangerous and fiscally irresponsible
political maneuver. AFSCME urges you to reject this
politically motivated and dangerous proposal.
Sincerely,
Scott Frey,
Director of Federal Government Affairs.
Mr. Speaker, let me read a couple of paragraphs from this letter from AFSCME.
``The proposed constitutional amendment is a draconian and unwise proposal that would damage the economy, result in huge job losses, and weaken vital public services that all Americans depend on. It unwisely requires outlays to match receipts each year regardless of economic conditions, a supermajority vote of three-fifths to increase the debt ceiling, with limited exceptions for outlays to exceed receipts only in times of war, but not during recessions or disasters.''
This is a false attempt to claim fiscal responsibility on the heels of a reckless tax cut projected to cause the deficit to skyrocket to $1.9 trillion over the next decade.
Mr. Speaker, let me read from the AARP letter. This is, as we know, AARP, the largest nonprofit, nonpartisan organization dedicated to empowering Americans over 50 on how they choose to live as they age. And
here is what they had to say: ``A balanced budget amendment would likely harm Social Security and Medicare, subjecting both programs to potentially deep cuts without regard to the impact on the health and financial security of individuals. It would also likely diminish the resources available for programs assisting Americans who are least able to provide for themselves--services such as meals or heating for those who are too poor or physically unable to take care of their basic needs without some support.''
Mr. Speaker, the letter goes on to say:
``The lack of a dependable Social Security and Medicare benefit would be devastating for millions of Americans. Social Security is currently the principal source of income for half of older American households receiving benefits, and roughly one in five households depend on Social Security benefits for nearly all . . . of their income. Over 50 million Americans depend on Medicare, half of whom have incomes of less than $24,150. Even small fluctuations in premiums and cost sharing would have a significant impact on the personal finances of older and disabled Americans.''
Mr. Speaker, I am here to say that we are in strong opposition to the so-called balanced budget amendment today. There is a word that has been thrown around in this discussion. Because I care about words, I wanted to make sure that I was using the right word for what is happening. So I looked in the dictionary, and I looked up the word ``hypocrisy.'' Here is the definition of hypocrisy: hypocrisy is the practice of claiming to have standards or beliefs to which one's own behavior does not conform. The dictionary definition goes on to say: a pretense.
That, Mr. Speaker, is what is happening, a pretense.
Mr. Speaker, I reserve the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, I yield myself the balance of my time to close.
Mr. Speaker, I mentioned the word ``hypocrisy.'' I mentioned the word ``pretense.'' If this was such an important issue, why did it not get proposed before the GOP tax scam? Because if the majority is really worried about the deficit, then they would not have passed a tax scam that cost this country $1.9 trillion simply to give tax cuts to the wealthiest individuals and corporations in our country.
This morning in the Budget Committee where I serve as vice ranking member, the Congressional Budget Office Director, Keith Hall, reaffirmed what we always knew, that these tax cuts do not pay for themselves. He also told us that there is no such thing as sustained growth of the rates that our Republican colleagues have thrown out there and said are going to happen.
So if the majority were worried about a balanced budget, they should have voted ``no'' on the GOP tax scam. But that is not what my Republican colleagues did. If they were worried about a balanced budget, then Republican colleagues should not have insisted on a $670 billion military spending budget. But we didn't hear a peep about this then. You can't just oppose spending, Mr. Speaker, when you don't like the things that we are spending on.
By the way, I have some breaking news: Republicans control the House, the Senate, and the Presidency. Republicans have control. But as we are seeing, that does not mean that Republicans know how to govern.
This amendment is a new low to showcase a contempt of the American people's memory and intelligence. But I believe that the American people are watching. They didn't buy the tax scam where they are now seeing that only 5 percent of those tax cuts are actually going to workers, and they are not going to believe in this maneuver either, Mr. Speaker.
Why? Because, as I said during the tax scam debate on the floor last year, the American people are going to rise up against any concerted and naked effort to cut earned benefit programs like Medicare and Social Security. I want to emphasize the words ``earned benefit'' because people call them entitlement programs, but Social Security is a program that people have contributed to with a promise that they would be taken care of when they retire.
But let's talk about the real purpose of this balanced budget amendment. It is similar to what I said on the floor last year in the middle of this debate, a three-step dance. Step one, pass a GOP tax scam to transfer $1.3 trillion in debt from working Americans to the wealthiest 1 percent and largest corporations.
Step two, explode the deficit--exactly what we heard from the CBO Director today--$2 trillion to the budget deficit over the next 10 years.
Step three, use those exploding deficits to justify deep cuts to the very programs that matter the most to Americans, Social Security, Medicare, and Medicaid.
We have already seen this strategy in the President's fiscal year 2019 budget which slashes $500 billion from Medicare, $1.4 trillion from Medicaid, and $72 billion from Social Security disability.
Mr. Speaker, it is not just the American people and Democrats in Congress who have noticed the hypocrisy of what is being proposed today. Even some Republicans in Congress have talked about it. Our colleague, Congressman Mark Meadows, said--and these are his words that I am quoting--``There is no one on Capitol Hill, and certainly no one on Main Street, that will take this vote seriously.''
He is right. This isn't going to fool anyone, least of all the American people.
Americans deserve so much better. My friend from Georgia talked earlier about how we both sit on the Budget Committee, and we have actually had conversations about how we wish we could actually talk about real solutions. That doesn't happen as often as it should, and certainly if you want to have a conversation about the deficit and the debt, we should have that. But to propose a balanced budget amendment after you have already voted for a tax cut that increased the deficit by $2 trillion over the next 10 years, that, I think, is something that people will see through. Americans will see through that just as they saw through whom the benefits of the tax cut are actually going to.
So, Mr. Speaker, today I urge all my colleagues to vote ``no'' on this amendment, and let's get back to the real work of serving the American people with real discussions and real questions that come up at the time when they are relevant.
Mr. Speaker, I yield back the balance of my time.
Mr. Speaker, on that I demand the yeas and nays.