Mr. Speaker, I recently attended the Conference on Anti- Semitism of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) in Berlin from April 28-29, 2004. I was privileged to attend as part of the official U.S. delegation, in my…
Mr. Speaker, I recently attended the Conference on Anti- Semitism of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe (OSCE) in Berlin from April 28-29, 2004. I was privileged to attend as part of the official U.S. delegation, in my capacity as the Ranking Member of the Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe (CSCE), commonly known as the Helsinki Commission. I was pleased to give a speech at the Berlin Conference, after visiting the concentration camps in Auschwitz, on the importance of fighting intolerance and speaking out against acts of anti-Semitism. Secretary of State Colin Powell attended the Conference and spoke forcefully about the need to combat anti-Semitism. Mr. Lantos of California, the Ranking Member of the International Relations Committee, has already introduced Secretary Powell's statement into the Record. The 55 Participating States of the OSCE adopted a strong action plan, the Berlin Declaration, which lays out specific steps for states to take regarding Holocaust education, data collection and monitoring of hate crimes against Jews, and improved coordination between non-governmental organizations and European law enforcement agencies.
During our Conference, on the evening of April 28, President Johannes Rau of Germany hosted a dinner for the President of the State of Israel Moshe Katsav. President Katsav spoke powerfully about the need to combat the rising tide of anti-Semitism throughout the world. Let me just highlight one section of President Katsav's remarks:
The violence against the Jews in Europe is evidence that
anti-Semitism, which we have not known since the Second World
War, is on the rise. This trend of the new anti-Semitism is a
result of the aggressive propaganda, made possible by modern
technologies, globalization and abuse of democracy and which
creates an infrastructure for developing and increasing anti-
Semitism, of a kind we have not known before * * * Many times
I have heard voices saying that anti-Semitism is not unique
and that it is no different from other kinds of racism. Anti-
Semitism should indeed receive special attention. Hatred
against the Jews has existed for many generations and it is
rooted in many cultures and continents through the world.
However, now anti-Semitism has become an instrument for
achieving political aims * * * The genocide of the Jews was
the result of anti-Semitism and was not caused by a war
between countries or a territorial conflict and, therefore,
anti-Semitism is a special danger for world Jewry and the
whole of Europe.
Let me draw my colleagues attention to a particularly important part of the Berlin Declaration, in which the OSCE participating States ``declare[d] unambiguously that international development of political issues, including those in Israel or elsewhere in the Middle East, never justify anti-Semitism.'' Let me be clear that I am not seeking to suppress legitimate criticism of Israel, just as I would not seek to silence those who criticize the policies of the U.S. Government. However, when individuals criticize the very existence of the Jewish state, equate Zionism with racism, and compare the Israeli Government to the Nazi regime, then all of us must say together: this is anti- Semitism, and you have crossed the line.
Mr. Speaker, I ask unanimous consent that the full text of the Israeli President's remarks at the President's Palace in Berlin be placed in the Record, and I urge my colleagues to read President Katsav's thoughtful remarks.
Address of the President of the State of Israel, Mr. Moshe Katsav, at
the President's Palace in Berlin
Mr. President, Ministers, Distinguished Guests, Heads of
Delegations:
It is very difficult and sad for me to stand here today in
Berlin, 60 years after the Holocaust and to speak about anti-
Semitism and the ways of fighting against it.
We, world Jewry, believed that after the terrible events of
the Holocaust, it would not be necessary to struggle against
anti-Semitism.
We believed that the world would not allow anti-Semitism to
raise its head.
We believed that anti-Semitism belonged to the old world
and to distant history.
We very much appreciate this gathering in Berlin. This step
to fight anti-Semitism sends a very important message that
this issue has a significant place in the European
agenda, in the relations between Israel and Europe and
between Europe and world Jewry. It is a sign that the
security of Jews touches directly basic human values.
I am standing here as a representative of a nation which
suffered a great deal during many generations of exiles,
inquisition and the terrible Holocaust-Shoah.
I represent a nation which desires to live in peace without
fear, without bloodshed, without incitement and without
violence.
I am standing here as a citizen of a democratic and free
world which is committed to the values of freedom, equality,
to universal values which oppose anti-Semitism.
Anti-Semitism is a big tragedy for the Jewish people. It is
a moral and historic failure for humanity. It is a failure of
world leaders. It is a failure of the free world.
If humanity does not express determination and does not
learn the historical lesson, the Holocaust will not remain an
abstract issue for the next generation.
Among international leaders, no one in 1933 believed that
the Holocaust would happen and, not even at the beginning of
the war in 1939. It is very difficult to believe but the
Holocaust happened in the heart of Europe, in one of the most
sophisticated countries in the world, which had the best
musicians, philosophers, scientists and researchers in the
world.
Lately we are witnessing again the burning of synagogues
and Jewish schools, the desecration of Jewish cemeteries and
horrible writings.
Jews are again afraid to walk in the streets with a Star of
David and a yarmulke. Jewish children are again a target of
violence and the streets of Europe are again not safe for
Jews, only because they are Jews.
Jews, as individuals and as a collective, are a target of
physical and emotional violence.
Hostile letters, graffiti and the use of the Internet and
the media are examples of instruments against the Jews.
For a long time Europe denied the rise in anti-Semitism.
The problem is not just the physical violence and damage
caused to Jewish institutions. We are concerned about the
hostility and incitement against the Jews and Israel in
Europe.
There are some who blame the Jews for an international
conspiracy and even blame them for the terrorist acts of
September 11th. They accuse American Jews of cooperating with
Israel in blaming Islam for these terrorist attacks.
We are witnessing a new trend by radical Muslims who are
recreating the classical blood libel and who are publishing
again the ``Protocols of the Elders of Zion'' which claim
that the Jews aim to control the world.
For others, the new anti-Semitism is a way of criticizing
the Jews and Israel for their treatment of the Palestinian
people.
In Europe the rise in classical antiSemitism, represents
the Jews and the Jewish state as brutal devils, the source of
wars and responsible for global disasters.
It is difficult for us to believe, but recently the public
opinion polls which were initiated by the European Commission
show that a majority of Europeans believe Israel is a danger
for the stability and peace in the world.
Not the non-democratic countries which are trying to
develop and achieve mass destruction weapons, not the
totalitarian countries which back terrorist organizations,
not the brutal bloodshed in the name of God, not poverty but
we, Israel, are a danger for world peace in the eyes of some
European people.
The violence against the Jews in Europe is evidence that
anti-Semitism, which we have not known since the Second World
War, is on the rise. This trend of the new anti-Semitism is a
result of the aggressive propaganda, made possible by modern
technologies, globalization and abuse of democracy and which
creates an infrastructure for developing and increasing anti-
Semitism, of a kind we have not known before.
Millions and millions of people are exposed to television
programs and Internet sites full of blood libels.
The silence, the closing of eyes and the slow reactions in
some countries permit this incitement to become deeper and
stronger.
It is impossible to fight against antiSemitism, while
permitting the demonization of Israel and its leaders and
denying its legitimate right to exist.
During the last decade we took historical steps towards the
Palestinian people. I would like to mention the Oslo
Agreement, the Camp David conference and the acceptance of
the Roadmap but during the last ten years we have had not
even one quiet day and we suffered from brutal and terrible
bloodshed.
Sometimes we feel that Europeans are not ready to feel
solidarity with us or to recognize the suffering of the
Israeli people from the terrible terrorism, which has
continued for many years.
The brutality of the terrorism in the Middle East is of a
type that humanity has never seen before.
It is only by cooperation, with determination and with
leadership that we can overcome this hatred.
We are astonished that there are still people who deny the
Holocaust.
The Durban Conference in September 2001 shocked all of us.
It was meant to be a conference against racism but became a
meeting of racists against the Jews and the State of Israel.
The anti-Semitism in Europe is a result of the cooperation
among elements who are against the West and western values,
who are against globalization and against progress, as well
as extremists from the left and right and from organizations
of radical Muslims.
The world of Islam is very large. There are more than a
billion people who are not of one mind and opinion. There are
some Muslim countries which have diplomatic relations with
Israel, such as Turkey, Egypt, the Hashemite Kingdom, the
Muslim Republics in Central Asia, Persian Gulf countries and
others. Not all Muslims are anti-Semitic and there is no
conflict between Judaism and Islam. In Europe there are 20
million Muslims. Most of them are very good people who desire
to live calm and normal lives. However, they are afraid to
raise their voices against the extremists. I call on the
moderate Muslims in Europe and on their leaders to cooperate
with us in encouraging tolerance and understanding for a free
and better world.
However, we must still remember that there are still Muslim
countries and organizations which are calling for the
destruction of the State of Israel.
Anti-Semitism is encouraged and is given inspiration by
international terrorism.
Anti-Semitism is a great danger to democracy and freedom in
the world.
Where synagogues are burnt, the day will come when stones
will be thrown on parliament and democracy is in danger.
Fighting against anti-Semitism with determination will
deliver a strong message to the international terrorist
organizations and will be a message that the free world has
determination to defend its values and is not prepared to
tolerate anti-Semitism, hostility and racism.
Anti-Semitism has no justification, no legitimacy and
should not be shown any understanding. Anti-Semitism is a
great threat to freedom. It uses human morality, democracy
and liberalism for its destructive aims.
Black people are not responsible for the racism against
them just as the Jews are not responsible for anti-Semitism.
We had hoped that the creation of a Jewish State would help
prevent anti-Semitism. We desired to be a free nation in our
homeland, like all nations. The Jewish state is a national
home for every Jew and we want to be sure that never again
will Jews be unprotected.
We are shocked by the accusations, which compare Israel to
Nazi Germany. There is a linkage between this incitement and
the violence against Jews in the streets of Europe.
We do not want to prevent legitimate political criticism
against Israeli government policy, but we will not tolerate
incitement against world Jewry and the Jewish state.
Many times I have heard voices saying that anti-Semitism is
not unique and that it is no different from other kinds of
racism. Anti-Semitism should indeed receive special
attention. Hatred against the Jews has existed for many
generations and it is rooted in many cultures and continents
throughout the world.
However, now anti-Semitism has become an instrument for
achieving political aims. It is being used by Muslims as an
instrument to achieve political gains.
The genocide of the Jews was the result of anti-Semitism
and was not caused by a war between countries or a
territorial conflict and, therefore, anti-Semitism is a
special danger for world Jewry and the whole of Europe.
Can it be that the impact of the Holocaust is not strong
enough to stop and prevent anti-Semitism? Can it be that the
impact of the Holocaust has become weaker in the last
decades?
We must focus all our efforts, energies and wisdom on
educational activities and research on the Holocaust. We must
transmit the lesson of the Holocaust to the young
generations.
I call to continue researching and documenting all the
events relating to the Holocaust.
We must teach the young generation human values.
I call on the European leaders to increase the awareness of
anti-Semitic acts in their countries, to research the origin
and background in each country and to evaluate anti-Semitism
on a national level.
I call for a mechanism for monitoring and controlling anti-
Semitic events and for ways to fight them.
I call for increased cooperation between the countries and
law enforcement authorities, in fighting anti-Semitism in
Europe.
I call for legislation to prevent anti-Semitism, especially
in the Internet and via satellite programs.
I call for a meeting of professionals from all over the
world to set up a program and take real steps against anti-
Semitism.
I greatly appreciate European governments and leaders who
are fighting against anti-Semitism and I very much appreciate
this important gathering in Berlin.
Most European countries have close relations with the Arab
countries which are responsible for producing incitement and
anti-Semitic propaganda on television, in books and in
newspapers which are distributed in Europe and around the
world.
We must put pressure on such countries to stop the
distribution of such terrible incitement against the Jews.
It is not enough to talk against anti-Semitism. We must
act.
I believe that European countries wish to do as much as
possible to stop anti-Semitism and give security to their
Jewish citizens.
European leaders have done a lot lately but not enough. It
is necessary to do more in the fields of education, public
opinion, legislation and law enforcement.
At this time, we the Jews are not alone. I can see many
good friends here who are standing with us. I am aware of
many people, nations and leaders who are struggling against
anti-Semitism, as they understand that anti-Semitism is a
danger to the stability and peace in the world, to human
values.
I am aware of European governments who are our partners in
our efforts and concern to provide security for every Jew and
they understand that Jews have the right to live without fear
anywhere.
I appreciate the governments in Europe who have already
appointed special ministerial committees for fighting anti-
Semitism. I appreciate countries whose parliaments dedicated
special sessions on the issue of anti-Semitism.
I appreciate those countries who have decided to strongly
condemn anti-Semitism in international bodies.
Indeed, now at the beginning of the 21st century, the
situation is very serious. There is an increase in violence
and an escalation of anti-Semitism against the Jews but there
is a big difference. We are not living in the thirties. We
have a Jewish, sovereign and independent state and this makes
a big difference.
We know what happened in the Second World War and what
racism brought upon the world and, because of this I am very
pleased that there is more awareness. Now leaders are more
sensitive and they protect their citizens. There is
legislation and law enforcement in many countries. The
leaders speak out and there are many seminars and conferences
against anti-Semitism. The strong position of the United
States of America in this matter is remarkable. I also very
much appreciate the position of the Vatican on this difficult
and tragic issue.
I am very sorry that the Irish proposal to the United
Nations General Assembly in December 2003, was not adopted,
because of the objection of some Muslim countries. It is very
sad that a special resolution which condemns anti-Semitism
and attacks against Jews cannot be passed now in the United
Nations.
The European Union should continue its efforts in this
important initiative and in all multilateral organizations,
in fighting against anti-Semitism.
We are very proud of our Jewish heritage and history. It is
a source of pride for world Jewry. I hope that the Jewish
people will also be a source of appreciation, understanding
and respect and not a target for hatred.
I hope and pray for cooperation for development, prosperity
and tolerance instead of destruction, bloodshed and hatred.
I would like to thank, you, President Rau and Foreign
Minister Joschka Fischer for this important initiative. I
believe that this meeting will be very constructive and that
it will help us achieve our mutual goals.
I hope that the Berlin Conference will serve as a basis for
continued efforts against anti-Semitism.
I wish to express my personal appreciation to President Rau
for his wise and moral leadership, for his great friendship
towards Israel and the Jewish people, and his personal
dedication to the fight against anti-Semitism.
We have the strength and the will to create a better world,
a just world for all humanity. Let us put all our efforts
together to make it possible. Let us work together.
Thank you.